Online 'censorship bill' unconstitutional: DA - TechCentral

Online ‘censorship bill’ unconstitutional: DA


If the Films and Publications Amendment Bill is passed in its current form, South Africans may no longer upload videos to online channels such as YouTube, Facebook, Twitter and Instagram unless they register as a distributor and pay a registration fee, the Democratic Alliance said at a media briefing on Monday.

The amendment, dubbed the “Internet Censorship Bill”, will be deliberated in parliament on Tuesday and it is, according to the DA, “simply bad news”.

DA spokeswoman communication, Phumzile Van Damme, claimed that government is increasingly overplaying its hand with regard to freedom of speech.

“There seems to be a firm hand in a broader project of censorship that is very worrying,” said Van Damme.

“The ‘Internet Censorship Bill’ in its current form gives government sweeping powers to censor content on the Internet,” she added.

The party cited problematic provisions in the bill that broadly fall into three categories: it’s unconstitutional, it uses broad and vague terminology and it gives the minister of communications extensive powers to impose penalties on transgressors.

Van Damme said the bill interferes with the powers of a chapter 9 institution — the Independent Communications Authority of South Africa — in that the body would not be allowed to issue or renew broadcasting licences unless the broadcaster is registered with the Film and Publication Board.

“The board cannot instruct Icasa when it may or may not issue or renew a broadcasting licence,” Van Damme said. “The board would overstep its mandate and infringe on the powers of a chapter 9 institution.”.

In addition, the bill seeks to curtail the distribution of digital films in that such content needs to be “pre-classified” by the Film and Publication Board. The terminology used in this provision is broad enough to include all digital videos and films — also user-generated video material — that are uploaded on social media platforms.

“This is clearly unworkable,” Van Damme said.

Phumzile Van Damme

Phumzile Van Damme

In addition, the bill also infringes on individuals’ right to privacy, according to the DA.

A section in the bill states that any person who distributes a film or game classified as “X18” must keep a register when access to the content is granted to a user. The user’s name, address and age will be captured in the register and the CEO of the Film and Publication Board will have access to this register.

“This is an unjustifiable breach of the right to privacy, which includes the right to not have your private communications infringed,” Van Damme said.

Although two specific amendments of the bill are to be welcomed — namely, the tightening of the definition of what constitutes child pornography and the outlawing of so-called revenge porn — the rest of the bill must be “thrown out”, Van Damme said.

“The legislation currently being pushed through parliament is unacceptable. The DA will do everything possible to ensure the bill does not pass in its current form,” she concluded.



  1. As a country, we are really battling to come to grips with technology convergence. By inserting ‘digital’ or ‘convergence’ in existing policy and regulatory frameworks doesn’t mean our ICT sector has converged. If the proposed restrictions on distribution of digital content are approved, what’s the point of having an up/down 100mb data line when there is no content to distribute? Why would Telcos invest in their infrastructure? We need industry experts who understand the ICT ecosystem drafting these Bill’s rather politicians, otherwise, we must kiss the economic growth that ICT brings….just look at Kenya!!

  2. If this does come to pass, I will make a killing selling access to the networks overseas, via cloaked VPN and strong encryption. The ANC can go suck on that, they are too stupid to even attempt to decrypt.

  3. Is anyone old enough, and was curious enough to find out the truth about the Soviet Union and Communist China?
    Well, I was always curious.
    Where South Africa is heading, is into the old Soviet Union with Chinese style oppression.
    Unfortunately there is only one real solution to all of this.
    South Africa is heading there now, thanks to the EFF.
    Just look at the violence in this country.
    The oppression we are heading for in less than the next 5 years will make apartheid seem like a playground tiff!

  4. The difference here was mentioned to us by Nelson Mandela in one of his speeches.
    He said “We must all work together to build a model African country with a model African economy like Zimbabwe”.
    For me that said the top officials milkbthe country dry enriching themselves, while all others starve.
    We can change this path on mass.
    But will we?

  5. You know it’s bad when it’s quicker to pick out what’s right with the bill than what’s wrong.

© 2009 – 2021 NewsCentral Media