Close Menu
TechCentralTechCentral

    Subscribe to the newsletter

    Get the best South African technology news and analysis delivered to your e-mail inbox every morning.

    Facebook X (Twitter) YouTube LinkedIn
    WhatsApp Facebook X (Twitter) LinkedIn YouTube
    TechCentralTechCentral
    • News
      The end of paying for phone calls in South Africa

      The end of paying for phone calls in South Africa

      17 November 2026
      SA's mobile operators are locked in a price war, Telkom says

      SA’s mobile operators are locked in a price war, Telkom says

      17 November 2026
      Telkom's first MVNO sells 1TB of prepaid mobile data for R800

      Telkom’s first MVNO sells 1TB of prepaid mobile data for R800

      17 November 2026
      Telkom becomes Amazon Leo's second South African distributor

      Telkom becomes Amazon Leo’s second South African distributor

      17 November 2026
      Ramaphosa's AI investment pitch in Silicon Valley - Cyril Ramaphosa

      Ramaphosa’s AI investment pitch in Silicon Valley

      17 November 2026
    • World
      Nvidia shuts the door on a Jensen Huang comeback

      Nvidia shuts the door on a Jensen Huang comeback

      17 November 2026
      Could Jensen Huang return to Nvidia?

      Jensen Huang weighs a comeback at Nvidia

      16 November 2026
      Intel sued by shareholders over 29% share price plunge - Intel CEO Lip-Bu Tan. Laure Andrillon/Reuters

      Intel sued by shareholders over 29% share price plunge

      16 November 2026
      Microsoft 364

      Microsoft outage hits the world

      13 November 2026
      The internet is roasting Jensen Huang with his own GPUs

      The internet is roasting Jensen Huang, using his own GPUs

      11 November 2026
    • In-depth
      Inside the 24 hours that broke Microsoft

      Inside the 24 hours that broke Microsoft

      16 November 2026
      Ducking hell: inside Apple's hidden list of words the iPhone won't suggest

      Ducking hell: inside Apple’s hidden list of words the iPhone won’t suggest

      6 November 2026
      Why investors are souring on Netflix

      Why investors are souring on Netflix

      22 October 2026

      10 days that changed the course of AI

      21 September 2026
      Meta to the AI industry: slow down without us - Mark Zuckerberg

      Meta to the AI industry: slow down without us

      16 September 2026
    • TCS
      TCS | Piet le Roux on Sakeliga's fight with Icasa over BEE

      TCS | Piet le Roux on Sakeliga’s fight with Icasa over BEE

      13 November 2026
      W&W | The AA’s Bobby Ramagwede on a car industry running out of road

      W&W | The AA’s Bobby Ramagwede on a car industry running out of road

      12 November 2026
      TCS | Pick n Pay fights back in online grocery wars - Vince Viviers

      TCS | Pick n Pay fights back in online grocery wars

      11 November 2026
      TCS | Nomvuyiso Batyi on the battle over Sim registration - Nomvuyiso Batyi

      TCS | Nomvuyiso Batyi on the battle over Sim registration

      9 November 2026
      TCS+ | Old Mutual's Celiwe Ross on leading people through AI - Old Mutual

      TCS+ | Old Mutual’s Celiwe Ross on leading people through AI

      6 November 2026
    • Opinion
      Icasa's Sim rules need a privacy backstop - Lloyd Matthew and Heinz Vollmer

      Icasa’s Sim rules need a privacy backstop

      5 November 2026
      AI's boardroom honeymoon is over - Gary Stocks

      AI’s boardroom honeymoon is over

      22 October 2026
      Before South Africa licenses Starlink, it should look at Ukraine - Duncan McLeod

      Before South Africa licenses Starlink, it should look at Ukraine

      21 October 2026
      Nonkqubela Thathakahle Jordan-Dyani

      Why cybersecurity is now a national security issue for South Africa

      15 October 2026
      When a machine can choose, who does it become? Fanie van Rooyen

      When a machine can choose, who does it become?

      9 October 2026
    • Company News
      • 1Stream
      • Africa Data Centres
      • AfriGIS
      • Altron Digital Business
      • Altron Document Solutions
      • Altron Group
      • Arctic Wolf
      • Ascent Technology
      • AvertITD
      • BBD
      • Braintree
      • CallMiner
      • CambriLearn
      • CM.com
      • Contactable
      • CYBER1 Solutions
      • Digicloud Africa
      • Digimune
      • Domains.co.za
      • ESET
      • Euphoria Telecom
      • HOSTAFRICA
      • Incredible Business
      • iONLINE
      • IQbusiness
      • Iris Network Systems
      • Kaspersky
      • LSD Open
      • Mitel
      • NEC XON
      • Netstar
      • Network Platforms
      • Next DLP
      • Ovations
      • Paracon
      • Paratus
      • Publishared
      • Q-KON
      • SevenC
      • SkyWire
      • Solid8 Technologies
      • Telit Cinterion
      • Telviva
      • Tenable
      • Vertiv
      • Videri Digital
      • Vodacom Business
      • Vox
      • Wipro
      • Workday
      • XLink
    • Sections
      • AI and machine learning
      • Banking
      • Broadcasting and media
      • Cloud services
      • Contact centres and CX
      • Cryptocurrencies
      • Education and skills
      • Electronics and hardware
      • Energy and sustainability
      • Enterprise software
      • Fintech and payments
      • HealthTech
      • Information security
      • Internet and connectivity
      • Internet of things
      • Investment
      • IT services
      • Lifestyle
      • Policy and regulation
      • Public sector
      • Retail and e-commerce
      • Satellite communications
      • Science
      • SMEs and start-ups
      • Social media
      • Talent and leadership
      • Telecoms
      • Watts & Wheels
    • Events
    • Advertise
    TechCentralTechCentral
    Home » Top » Straw Dogs: Hollywood versus Tea Party evil

    Straw Dogs: Hollywood versus Tea Party evil

    By Editor21 November 2011
    Twitter LinkedIn Facebook WhatsApp Email Telegram Copy Link
    Get breaking news on WhatsApp

    Amy get your gun

    Few films have provoked as much controversy and heated debate as Straw Dogs, the classic 1971 revenge thriller from Sam Peckinpah. Pauline Kael, an admirer of the director, famously called it “the first American film that is a fascist work of art” — and that was in a review that was mostly positive.

    Roger Ebert, one of the few critics to recognise Peckinpah’s earlier blood ballet The Wild Bunch as a classic upon its release, detested Straw Dogs for its commitment to “the pornography of violence”. Forty years later, Straw Dogs is still condemned and defended as passionately as A Clockwork Orange, which was released in the same year.

    Rod Lurie’s pointless new remake of the landmark film, by contrast, provokes little more than mild irritation. Lurie — the director of exercises in wet liberalism such as The Last Castle and The Contender — tries to smooth away the rough edges of Peckinpah’s tough-minded film to make it more palatable.

    He dispenses with Peckinpah’s moral ambiguities. The Lurie version is more immoral than Peckinpah’s version as a result — an ideological fudge with a smug subtext about how Hollywood sees itself as a vanguard against the barbarism of Tea Party conservatism.

    For Lurie’s version, the action of the home invasion thriller is transplanted from the remote reaches of rural England to the Deep South of the US,  though it follows the story that Peckinpah took from the novel The Siege of Trencher’s Farm fairly closely.

    David Sumner, in this version an LA scriptwriter played by James Marsden, takes his actress wife Amy (Kate Bosworth) back to her hometown for the first time in years. Here, he hopes to knuckle down and finish a script at her late father’s isolated farmstead.

    But tensions begin to simmer between the Hollywood couple and the local yokels, particularly a former high school football hero who used to date Amy. The friction quickly escalates into open conflict, culminating in an orgy of bloodletting as David tries to protect his home and wife from the enraged rednecks in the film’s infamous climactic siege.

    James Marsden and Kate Bosworth as a Hollywood couple in Lurie’s Straw Dogs

    Peckinpah used this material to explore the animal heart beating in the chest of the most mild-mannered man. His film is about the irony of civilisation: that it is only upheld by the threat of violence. It is David’s moral and physical cowardice that sets the terrible events of the film in motion. Lurie, however, says his film is about a man finding his inner hero. For his next film, he should consider remaking Taxi Driver as a man’s journey to sanity.

    Though Peckinpah’s original is often condemned as a celebration of violence, this is a criticism that is actually more valid for Lurie’s version. The audience shares David’s ghoulish delight in the carnage of Peckinpah’s film, but this is balanced by a downbeat denouement hinting at the horrors in the wreckage. Lurie’s film ends on a note of triumphalism that is far more sickening than the conclusion of Peckinpah’s Straw Dogs.

    Peckinpah’s film, for all of its ugliness, treats the audience like adults. Not so Lurie’s version, which is replete with heavy-handed metaphors, such as the fact that David is working on a script about the Battle of Stalingrad. Peckinpah trusted you to work out the meaning of his title; Lurie explains his interpretation in a contrived piece of dialogue.

    Rampaging rednecks in a pick-up truck

    X-Men star Marsden is an interesting casting decision for David, one clearly meant to escape comparisons with Dustin Hoffman’s subtle performance in the original film. But turning David from a nerdy mathematician into a handsome, Harvard-educated member of the Hollywood elite robs him of any audience sympathy.

    His self-satisfied grin, the way he throws his cash around in a backwater town and his condescension to the locals endear him to the audience as little as they do to the townsfolk. Perhaps the biggest failing of Marsden’s performance is that he is not able to sell the crucial moment when David breaks and decides to fight back.

    Amy, a character roughly used by Peckinpah, is arguably treated even more despicably than she was in the original. As portrayed by Bosworth, she’s alternately coquettish and shrewish, a character lacking in the psychological dimensions that Susan George originally brought to her.

    In Peckinpah’s film, Amy is attracted to David because he is kinder and gentler than men like Charlie, but despises him for his timidity. Here, it’s not entirely clear what she saw in him in the first place. The fact that the relationship between the two doesn’t work destroys the central dramatic conflict of the film.

    The strongest performances come from the supporting cast of villains, notably James Woods as a washed-up alcoholic football coach and rising star Alexander Skarsgård as Amy’s former boyfriend Charlie.

    Sam Peckinpah’s Straw Dogs (via YouTube):

    Rod Lurie’s Straw Dogs (via YouTube):

    Skarsgård’s performance, hinting at the seething resentment and disappointed dreams under the Southern deference Charlie initially shows the Hollywood couple, is better than the huntin’, shootin’ and God-fearin’ grab-bag of redneck clichés he is given to work with.

    Lurie’s Straw Dogs is the worst sort of remake — a vulgarisation that displays both contempt for and a lack of understanding of its source material. Peckinpah’s original is problematic in many ways, especially its gender politics, but it is also a stunning example of the bravura filmmaking technique of one of the greatest action directors of all time.

    Just compare the masterful use of space and mise-en-scene in the siege scene or the economy with which Peckinpah sets up the conflicts between his characters to the clumsiness of Lurie’s version, for example. More than that, it has some artistic integrity and psychological depth to it, which is more than can be said for Lurie’s hack job.  — Lance Harris, TechCentral

    Read more:

    • Straw Dogs’ art legacy
    • Why Rod Lurie does not get Peckinpah
    • Subscribe to our free daily newsletter
    • Follow us on Twitter or on Google+ or on Facebook
    • Visit our sister website, SportsCentral (still in beta)
    Add TechCentral as a preferred source on GoogleFollow TechCentral on Google NewsGet breaking news on WhatsApp


    Lance Harris Straw Dogs
    WhatsApp YouTube
    Share. Facebook Twitter LinkedIn WhatsApp Telegram Email Copy Link
    Previous ArticleIncubeta buys Interface for R100m
    Next Article Telkom confirms faster broadband plans

    Related Posts

    TechCentral’s top 10 movies of 2019

    31 December 2019

    TechCentral’s top 10 games of 2019

    23 December 2019

    The best movies of 2018

    31 December 2018
    Company News
    HOSTAFRICA's HCode puts AI-built apps online for R50 a month

    HOSTAFRICA’s HCode puts AI-built apps online for R50 a month

    17 November 2026
    Every agent is a database user - Ascent Technology, Johan Lamberts

    Every agent is a database user

    16 November 2026
    Ebenezer Smith, CEO of PSET

    After universities and TVET colleges, PSET is going to schools

    16 November 2026
    Opinion
    Icasa's Sim rules need a privacy backstop - Lloyd Matthew and Heinz Vollmer

    Icasa’s Sim rules need a privacy backstop

    5 November 2026
    AI's boardroom honeymoon is over - Gary Stocks

    AI’s boardroom honeymoon is over

    22 October 2026
    Before South Africa licenses Starlink, it should look at Ukraine - Duncan McLeod

    Before South Africa licenses Starlink, it should look at Ukraine

    21 October 2026

    Subscribe to Updates

    Get the best South African technology news and analysis delivered to your e-mail inbox every morning.

    Latest Posts
    The end of paying for phone calls in South Africa

    The end of paying for phone calls in South Africa

    17 November 2026
    SA's mobile operators are locked in a price war, Telkom says

    SA’s mobile operators are locked in a price war, Telkom says

    17 November 2026
    Telkom's first MVNO sells 1TB of prepaid mobile data for R800

    Telkom’s first MVNO sells 1TB of prepaid mobile data for R800

    17 November 2026
    Telkom becomes Amazon Leo's second South African distributor

    Telkom becomes Amazon Leo’s second South African distributor

    17 November 2026
    © 2009 - 2026 NewsCentral Media
    Built and maintained by Chronon
    • Cookie policy (ZA)
    • TechCentral – privacy and Popia

    Type above and press Enter to search. Press Esc to cancel.

    Manage consent

    TechCentral uses cookies to enhance its offerings. Consenting to these technologies allows us to serve you better. Not consenting or withdrawing consent may adversely affect certain features and functions of the website.

    Functional Always active
    The technical storage or access is strictly necessary for the legitimate purpose of enabling the use of a specific service explicitly requested by the subscriber or user, or for the sole purpose of carrying out the transmission of a communication over an electronic communications network.
    Preferences
    The technical storage or access is necessary for the legitimate purpose of storing preferences that are not requested by the subscriber or user.
    Statistics
    The technical storage or access that is used exclusively for statistical purposes. The technical storage or access that is used exclusively for anonymous statistical purposes. Without a subpoena, voluntary compliance on the part of your Internet Service Provider, or additional records from a third party, information stored or retrieved for this purpose alone cannot usually be used to identify you.
    Marketing
    The technical storage or access is required to create user profiles to send advertising, or to track the user on a website or across several websites for similar marketing purposes.
    • Manage options
    • Manage services
    • Manage {vendor_count} vendors
    • Read more about these purposes
    View preferences
    • {title}
    • {title}
    • {title}
    🇿🇦 Sign up to the TechCentral newsletter