TechCentralTechCentral
    Facebook Twitter YouTube LinkedIn
    Facebook Twitter LinkedIn YouTube
    TechCentralTechCentral
    NEWSLETTER
    • News

      Standard Bank IT spending tops R10-billion in six months

      19 August 2022

      Hungry Prosus to splurge up to R30.7-billion on iFood stake

      19 August 2022

      Koeberg unit shut down due to mechanical fault

      19 August 2022

      Blue Label expects robust full-year earnings growth

      19 August 2022

      Sarb tells banks they should work with crypto exchanges

      18 August 2022
    • World

      15 September pegged as target date for ethereum’s big ‘Merge’

      19 August 2022

      Qualcomm gets serious about servers

      19 August 2022

      China blasts US over ‘discriminatory’ Chips Act

      18 August 2022

      Tencent reports first-ever sales decline

      17 August 2022

      Chip makers are flashing a big warning for the global economy

      17 August 2022
    • In-depth

      Are you a chronic procrastinator? Read this!

      18 August 2022

      Semiconductor boom turns to bust

      16 August 2022

      African unicorn Flutterwave battles fires on multiple fronts

      11 August 2022

      The length of Earth’s days has been increasing – and no one knows why

      7 August 2022

      As Facebook fades, the Mad Men of advertising stage a comeback

      2 August 2022
    • Podcasts

      Qush on infosec: why prevention is always better than cure

      11 August 2022

      e4’s Adri Führi on encouraging more women into tech careers

      10 August 2022

      How South Africa can woo more women into tech

      4 August 2022

      Book and check-in via WhatsApp? FlySafair is on it

      28 July 2022

      Interview: Why Dell’s next-gen PowerEdge servers change the game

      28 July 2022
    • Opinion

      How AI could transform financial services in emerging markets

      19 August 2022

      No reason South Africa should have a shortage of electricity: Ramaphosa

      11 July 2022

      Ntshavheni’s bias against the private sector

      8 July 2022

      South Africa can no longer rely on Eskom alone

      4 July 2022

      Has South Africa’s advertising industry lost its way?

      21 June 2022
    • Company Hubs
      • 1-grid
      • Africa Data Centres
      • Altron Document Solutions
      • Amplitude
      • Atvance Intellect
      • Axiz
      • BOATech
      • CallMiner
      • Digital Generation
      • E4
      • ESET
      • Euphoria Telecom
      • IBM
      • Kyocera Document Solutions
      • Microsoft
      • Nutanix
      • One Trust
      • Pinnacle
      • Skybox Security
      • SkyWire
      • Tarsus on Demand
      • Videri Digital
      • Zendesk
    • Sections
      • Banking
      • Broadcasting and Media
      • Cloud computing
      • Consumer electronics
      • Cryptocurrencies
      • Education and skills
      • Energy
      • Fintech
      • Information security
      • Internet and connectivity
      • Internet of Things
      • Investment
      • IT services
      • Motoring and transport
      • Public sector
      • Science
      • Social media
      • Talent and leadership
      • Telecoms
    • Advertise
    TechCentralTechCentral
    Home»Opinion»Duncan McLeod»How to fix the ICT policy white paper

    How to fix the ICT policy white paper

    Duncan McLeod By Duncan McLeod9 November 2016
    Facebook Twitter LinkedIn WhatsApp Telegram Email

    Duncan-McLeod-180-profileThe department of telecommunications & postal services’s new director-general, Robert Nkuna, is going to have no time to ease gently into his new office in Hatfield, Pretoria. Indeed, he’s going to have to hit the ground running.

    The former councillor at communications regulator Icasa and special adviser to former communications minister Yunus Carrim is tasked with putting the national integrated ICT policy white paper, developed by former acting DG Joe Mjwara, into effect.

    The comprehensive document, which will upend the ICT sector, has many things going for it. It (finally) introduces guidelines for the rapid deployment of infrastructure, which will make it much easier for operators to build networks. And its proposals on net neutrality seem to be well thought through (even if they’re perhaps not needed yet). But, as many contributors to this website in recent weeks have pointed out, there are also fundamental problems with the document, which, if implemented, threaten to do enormous and unnecessary damage to the ICT sector.

    I’m not going rehash the excellent contributions from people like Alison Gillwald of Research ICT Africa and Denis Smit from BMI-TechKnowledge — I encourage you to go and read (or re-read) their views on the subject. Instead, I’d like to use this space to propose a middle path, one that secures continued investment by the big mobile operators (which the white paper as it stands does not) while also encouraging greater competition and helping new entrants, including black companies, get into the industry.

    The problem with the white paper is that it wants to throw the baby out with the bath water. Or, to use another hackneyed phrase, it wants to kill the goose that lays the golden eggs. And for what?

    It is clear from reading the white paper, and from listening to government officials such as Mjwara and telecoms minister Siyabonga Cwele, that they want the status quo to change. Mjwara says as much in this piece he wrote for TechCentral, in which he says small and medium enterprises have been kept out of the industry.

    And that means doing something about the “duopoly” of Vodacom and MTN, South Africa’s two most successful mobile operators. There’s a perception (perhaps it’s a correct one, I don’t know) that these two companies are too dominant; that their size and sway prevents new entrants from challenging them effectively.

    The solution, in the white paper, is to allocate all future spectrum assignments for mobile (the so-called “high demand” spectrum) to a new wireless wholesale open-access network, or Woan, in which all industry players are invited to participate. This new entity would, in effect, have a monopoly over infrastructure deployment.

    The policy document goes even further, raising the possibility of taking away already-assigned spectrum that companies like Vodacom, Telkom, MTN and Cell C have used to build their 2G, 3G and 4G networks. Talk is that this clause is going to be removed from the white paper — that’s good, because it was probably unconstitutional. But the plan to assign all future high-demand spectrum to the Woan is almost as troubling – for reasons I have set out in a previous column.

    Robert Nkuna
    Robert Nkuna

    The problem, in short, is not that government wants to experiment with a Woan-type model, it is that it wants to do it at the exclusion of everything else, including what’s worked so well until now.

    The Woan model has been attempted in a few markets around the world, including Mexico, which is often cited as a case study by the telecoms minister. But none of those markets has done it to the exclusion of everything else — Mexico reserved only the 700MHz band for its Woan, for example — and none is yet a demonstrable success. Nowhere is there a case study that shows conclusively this model works.

    In South Africa, government wants all spectrum in the 700MHz, 800MHz and 2,6GHz bands — among others, no doubt — reserved exclusively for the Woan. That is an insane amount of spectrum to reserve for a single entity and, technically, is completely unnecessary. And there’s no guarantee the big operators — MTN and Vodacom specifically — will co-invest in the Woan. Every indication is that they intend fighting it.

    Whether one likes the vertically integrated approach taken by Vodacom and MTN — where they build and own their own infrastructure and billing and distribution systems from top to bottom — the fact is the model has created enormous wealth and distributed telephony to tens of millions of South Africans. This year, the two companies are investing about R20bn in total in their networks. And, with the smaller operators, they have extended coverage to just about the entire country — the populated parts of it, anyway. This is not the definition of “market failure”, a term often used by politicians to describe an industry they want to meddle in.

    Are prices too high? On voice, no, not anymore. Lower interconnection fees — a proactive and positive intervention by the regulator — coupled with robust competition from the third and fourth operators (Cell C and Telkom) have ensured that rates have come down. On data, there’s certainly an argument that prices are still too high. Operators don’t do themselves any favours with R2/MB out-of-bundle charges, R149/GB data bundles and too aggressive data expiry (sometimes as short as 30 days). This sort of behaviour has earned them bad PR and they’d be well advised to be more customer-friendly. On the other hand, they need access to more spectrum to give them greater flexibility to cut prices so their networks can cope with demand.

    tower-640

    But choking off their air supply — cutting their access to more spectrum — as the white paper proposes is not the right way to achieve government’s policy objective of making it more affordable for South Africans to communicate.

    There are better ways to make the market more competitive and bring down prices.

    The idea of a Woan is not a bad one — it just mustn’t have a monopoly over spectrum. A Woan could work, especially for smaller players like Internet service providers, that can’t afford to build networks of national scope on their own.

    If ISPs and smaller telecoms operators were to pool their resources, they could build an open-access network that presents a real challenge to the big incumbents. Spectrum is a limited resource, but there’s certainly enough of it available to allocate a decent chunk to a Woan. It could even be licensed at low cost outside of a formal auction process, while those seeking exclusive-use spectrum could be subjected to an auction plus higher (but not prohibitive) annual licence fees.

    In this way, South Africa would benefit from the best of both worlds. The Woan could provide much-needed additional competition to the big incumbents, driving down prices, while not stopping the big boys from continuing with their investments based on a business model that makes sense to them and which has proved successful.

    But making changes of this magnitude to the white paper this late in the process — a white paper is the last step to amending legislation or creating new laws — is going to require determination and guts from Nkuna. The new DG could choose the easier path of simply seeking to implement the policy as it stands (although it will then be challenged in court). Or he could try and find a middle ground, one that doesn’t risk investment, but one that could put him at loggerheads with Mjwara and other senior people in the ANC.

    For the sake of the sector and of the country, let’s hope he chooses the latter course.

    • Duncan McLeod is editor of TechCentral
    Alison Gillwald Cell C Denis Smit Duncan McLeod Icasa Joe Mjwara MTN Robert Nkuna Siyabonga Cwele Telkom Vodacom Yunus Carrim
    Share. Facebook Twitter LinkedIn WhatsApp Telegram Email
    Previous ArticleNew protector must probe Thuli: ANC
    Next Article SA operators to launch IoT networks

    Related Posts

    How AI could transform financial services in emerging markets

    19 August 2022

    Blue Label expects robust full-year earnings growth

    19 August 2022

    Telkom muscles into banks’ turf with business loans

    18 August 2022
    Add A Comment

    Comments are closed.

    Promoted

    Does your contact centre have the CX factor?

    19 August 2022

    Entelek, A2pay to roll out 2 500 free Wi-Fi sites in South Africa

    18 August 2022

    Companies are drowning in data – but solutions are at hand

    18 August 2022
    Opinion

    How AI could transform financial services in emerging markets

    19 August 2022

    No reason South Africa should have a shortage of electricity: Ramaphosa

    11 July 2022

    Ntshavheni’s bias against the private sector

    8 July 2022

    Subscribe to Updates

    Get the best South African technology news and analysis delivered to your e-mail inbox every morning.

    © 2009 - 2022 NewsCentral Media

    Type above and press Enter to search. Press Esc to cancel.