TechCentralTechCentral
    Facebook Twitter YouTube LinkedIn
    Facebook Twitter LinkedIn YouTube
    TechCentralTechCentral
    NEWSLETTER
    • News

      Fixing SA’s power crisis is not complex: it simply takes the will to do better

      12 August 2022

      Consortium makes unsolicited bid for state’s 40% stake in Telkom

      12 August 2022

      Actually, solar users should pay more to access the grid – here’s why

      12 August 2022

      Telkom says MTN talks remain on track

      12 August 2022

      Analysis | Rain muddies the waters with approach to Telkom

      11 August 2022
    • World

      Tencent woes mount, even after $560-billion selloff

      12 August 2022

      Huawei just booked its first sales rise since US blacklisting

      12 August 2022

      Apple remains upbeat about iPhone sales even as Android world suffers

      12 August 2022

      Ether at two-month high as upgrade to blockchain passes major test

      12 August 2022

      Gaming industry’s fortunes fade as pandemic ends

      11 August 2022
    • In-depth

      African unicorn Flutterwave battles fires on multiple fronts

      11 August 2022

      The length of Earth’s days has been increasing – and no one knows why

      7 August 2022

      As Facebook fades, the Mad Men of advertising stage a comeback

      2 August 2022

      Crypto breaks the rules. That’s the point

      27 July 2022

      E-mail scams are getting chillingly personal

      17 July 2022
    • Podcasts

      Qush on infosec: why prevention is always better than cure

      11 August 2022

      e4’s Adri Führi on encouraging more women into tech careers

      10 August 2022

      How South Africa can woo more women into tech

      4 August 2022

      Book and check-in via WhatsApp? FlySafair is on it

      28 July 2022

      Interview: Why Dell’s next-gen PowerEdge servers change the game

      28 July 2022
    • Opinion

      No reason South Africa should have a shortage of electricity: Ramaphosa

      11 July 2022

      Ntshavheni’s bias against the private sector

      8 July 2022

      South Africa can no longer rely on Eskom alone

      4 July 2022

      Has South Africa’s advertising industry lost its way?

      21 June 2022

      Rob Lith: What Icasa’s spectrum auction means for SA companies

      13 June 2022
    • Company Hubs
      • 1-grid
      • Altron Document Solutions
      • Amplitude
      • Atvance Intellect
      • Axiz
      • BOATech
      • CallMiner
      • Digital Generation
      • E4
      • ESET
      • Euphoria Telecom
      • IBM
      • Kyocera Document Solutions
      • Microsoft
      • Nutanix
      • One Trust
      • Pinnacle
      • Skybox Security
      • SkyWire
      • Tarsus on Demand
      • Videri Digital
      • Zendesk
    • Sections
      • Banking
      • Broadcasting and Media
      • Cloud computing
      • Consumer electronics
      • Cryptocurrencies
      • Education and skills
      • Energy
      • Fintech
      • Information security
      • Internet and connectivity
      • Internet of Things
      • Investment
      • IT services
      • Motoring and transport
      • Public sector
      • Science
      • Social media
      • Talent and leadership
      • Telecoms
    • Advertise
    TechCentralTechCentral
    Home»Opinion»Alistair Fairweather»Vodacom, MTN put profits before people

    Vodacom, MTN put profits before people

    Alistair Fairweather By Alistair Fairweather10 February 2014
    Facebook Twitter LinkedIn WhatsApp Telegram Email

    Alistair-Fairweather-180-profileI often wonder if certain captains of industries are entirely disconnected from reality. It’s the only thing that can explain the breathtaking gall of Vodacom CEO Shameel Joosub, who complained publicly that new regulations would cost his company R1bn in 2015, threatening to sue as a result.

    His threat relates to the upcoming changes in mobile termination rates enforced by the Independent Communications Authority of South Africa (Icasa). These are the fees that our cellphone networks are allowed to charge each other when customers call numbers outside of their own network.

    After years of squabbling, Icasa has finally managed to force the larger operators to gradually reduce these fees from 56c/minute in 2012 to 20c/minute starting in March this year, and down to 10c/minute by 2016.

    Let’s be clear: we are not talking about Vodacom or MTN suddenly being unfairly fined or taxed. These termination fees are built into the cost of the phone calls we make. By forcing the operators to lower them, Icasa is acting on behalf of ordinary consumers because lowering these fees will stimulate competition and drive down call charges across the industry.

    So what Joosub is effectively saying is this: “Vodacom looked at the numbers and these lower call rates will hurt profits. We like profits, so we’re (probably) suing Icasa.” Were Vodacom some kind of struggling nongovernmental organisation — a scheme to dig wells for the impoverished in South Sudan, say — we might have some sympathy. But Vodacom is a spectacularly profitable giant with over 50% of the South African market in its grasp.

    In the year ending December 2013, Vodacom declared more than R13,2bn in pure profit — a rise of nearly 30% on the previous year. So the amount Joosub is complaining about does not even equal 10% of last year’s profits. By 2015, it will probably be closer to 5%. Shame.

    One of the things that is most vexing to Joosub and his compatriots at MTN (which controls a healthy 33% of the market) is that Icasa has decided to treat the smaller networks — Cell C and Telkom Mobile — differently. They will receive much higher termination fees from Vodacom and MTN than they pay in return.

    The logic behind this decision is that the larger players, left unchecked, might exercise their market power to squeeze the smaller players out completely. I’m normally not a fan of such blatant market manipulation by a regulator, but given the alternative — a predatory duopoly — I’m comfortable with the idea.

    And it is pleasingly ironic to watch Telkom argue that it needs special treatment to help it defeat mean old Vodacom, in which it owned a 50% stake until mid-2009. The spectacle of one rapacious monopolist stabbing another former comrade-in-monopoly in the back is grimly amusing. The fact that consumers may benefit as a result is purely coincidental, but with Telkom’s history I suppose we’ll take what scraps we can get.

    You could argue that Joosub and Zunaid Bulbulia — MTN South Africa’s CEO — are just doing their jobs. They are protecting their shareholders — many of them ordinary South Africans — against a regulator that blatantly seeks to make their companies less profitable.

    But let’s look at their profit margins in comparison to international norms. In its last financial year, Vodacom’s net profit margin was 22,2% and MTN Group’s was 17,8%. In the previous year, the figures were 17,5% and 19,5% respectively. International averages for the industry hover around 10%, and 15% is considered very high.

    money-phone-640

    Profit margins are meant to reflect risk. Supermarkets make lower margins than many riskier businesses because the chance of people not needing food regularly is zero. But they make up for this in volumes.

    I’d argue that mature telecoms operators are much more like supermarkets than riskier businesses such as software or construction. They have huge, established customer bases and provide a daily service to even the poorest people. They simply do not deserve the large risk premium they are currently extracting from the market. So, bitching about giving 5% of your enormous profits back to your customers will only come across as tin-eared and out of touch.

    Oscar Wilde once said: “One should always play fairly when one has the winning cards.” If I were Joosub or Bulbulia, I would take that to heart and shut my mouth.  — (c) 2014 Mail & Guardian

    Update: A representative of Vodacom contacted me to voice the company’s concerns about some of the facts in my column. The company insists that it is not against lower mobile termination rates, or even the asymmetry in those rates. It is only seeking to challenge the method Icasa used to determine the scale of that asymmetry, which it claims is unprecedented. It also feels that characterising Joosub’s statements about the R1bn loss as a “complaint” is unfair. He stated the amount as a fact in response to a question during a call to analysts, not as a comment on the fairness of the rates.

    • Alistair Fairweather is chief technology officer at the Mail & Guardian
    • Visit the Mail & Guardian Online, the smart news source
    Alistair Fairweather Cell C Icasa MTN Shameel Joosub Telkom Telkom Mobile Vodacom Zunaid Bulbulia
    Share. Facebook Twitter LinkedIn WhatsApp Telegram Email
    Previous ArticleCarrim welcomes Post Office probe
    Next Article Challengers may own Africa’s Internet future

    Related Posts

    Consortium makes unsolicited bid for state’s 40% stake in Telkom

    12 August 2022

    Telkom says MTN talks remain on track

    12 August 2022

    Analysis | Rain muddies the waters with approach to Telkom

    11 August 2022
    Add A Comment

    Comments are closed.

    Promoted

    Get your brand in front of TechCentral’s amazing audience

    12 August 2022

    Pricing Beyond CMYK: printers answer the FAQs

    11 August 2022

    How secure is your cloud?

    10 August 2022
    Opinion

    No reason South Africa should have a shortage of electricity: Ramaphosa

    11 July 2022

    Ntshavheni’s bias against the private sector

    8 July 2022

    South Africa can no longer rely on Eskom alone

    4 July 2022

    Subscribe to Updates

    Get the best South African technology news and analysis delivered to your e-mail inbox every morning.

    © 2009 - 2022 NewsCentral Media

    Type above and press Enter to search. Press Esc to cancel.