Close Menu
TechCentralTechCentral

    Subscribe to the newsletter

    Get the best South African technology news and analysis delivered to your e-mail inbox every morning.

    Facebook X (Twitter) YouTube LinkedIn
    WhatsApp Facebook X (Twitter) LinkedIn YouTube
    TechCentralTechCentral
    • News
      New tech retailer opens in South Africa, promising to undercut rivals - Amber Dendy Young

      New tech retailer opens in South Africa, promising to undercut rivals

      20 November 2026
      Meet the CIO | Wits's Stanley Mpofu on taking campus Wi-Fi to malls and libraries

      Meet the CIO | Wits’s Stanley Mpofu on taking campus Wi-Fi to malls and libraries

      20 November 2026
      Caby takes on Uber and Bolt in Cape Town - Denise Walker

      Caby takes on Uber and Bolt in Cape Town

      20 November 2026
      Tencent props up Naspers as iFood and Just Eat spending bites - Fabricio Bloisi

      Tencent props up Naspers as iFood and Just Eat spending bites

      20 November 2026
      MTN, Telkom and the price of consolidation

      MTN, Telkom and the price of consolidation

      19 November 2026
    • World
      Critical Java bug could let hackers take over servers

      Critical Java bug could let hackers take over servers

      19 November 2026
      Nvidia shuts the door on a Jensen Huang comeback

      Nvidia shuts the door on a Jensen Huang comeback

      17 November 2026
      Could Jensen Huang return to Nvidia?

      Jensen Huang weighs a comeback at Nvidia

      16 November 2026
      Intel sued by shareholders over 29% share price plunge - Intel CEO Lip-Bu Tan. Laure Andrillon/Reuters

      Intel sued by shareholders over 29% share price plunge

      16 November 2026
      Microsoft 364

      Microsoft outage hits the world

      13 November 2026
    • In-depth
      Inside the 24 hours that broke Microsoft

      Inside the 24 hours that broke Microsoft

      16 November 2026
      Ducking hell: inside Apple's hidden list of words the iPhone won't suggest

      Ducking hell: inside Apple’s hidden list of words the iPhone won’t suggest

      6 November 2026
      Why investors are souring on Netflix

      Why investors are souring on Netflix

      22 October 2026

      10 days that changed the course of AI

      21 September 2026
      Meta to the AI industry: slow down without us - Mark Zuckerberg

      Meta to the AI industry: slow down without us

      16 September 2026
    • TCS
      TCS | Piet le Roux on Sakeliga's fight with Icasa over BEE

      TCS | Piet le Roux on Sakeliga’s fight with Icasa over BEE

      13 November 2026
      W&W | The AA’s Bobby Ramagwede on a car industry running out of road

      W&W | The AA’s Bobby Ramagwede on a car industry running out of road

      12 November 2026
      TCS | Pick n Pay fights back in online grocery wars - Vince Viviers

      TCS | Pick n Pay fights back in online grocery wars

      11 November 2026
      TCS | Nomvuyiso Batyi on the battle over Sim registration - Nomvuyiso Batyi

      TCS | Nomvuyiso Batyi on the battle over Sim registration

      9 November 2026
      TCS+ | Old Mutual's Celiwe Ross on leading people through AI - Old Mutual

      TCS+ | Old Mutual’s Celiwe Ross on leading people through AI

      6 November 2026
    • Opinion
      Icasa's Sim rules need a privacy backstop - Lloyd Matthew and Heinz Vollmer

      Icasa’s Sim rules need a privacy backstop

      5 November 2026
      AI's boardroom honeymoon is over - Gary Stocks

      AI’s boardroom honeymoon is over

      22 October 2026
      Before South Africa licenses Starlink, it should look at Ukraine - Duncan McLeod

      Before South Africa licenses Starlink, it should look at Ukraine

      21 October 2026
      Nonkqubela Thathakahle Jordan-Dyani

      Why cybersecurity is now a national security issue for South Africa

      15 October 2026
      When a machine can choose, who does it become? Fanie van Rooyen

      When a machine can choose, who does it become?

      9 October 2026
    • Company News
      • 1Stream
      • Africa Data Centres
      • AfriGIS
      • Altron Digital Business
      • Altron Document Solutions
      • Altron Group
      • Arctic Wolf
      • Ascent Technology
      • AvertITD
      • BBD
      • Braintree
      • CallMiner
      • CambriLearn
      • CM.com
      • Contactable
      • CYBER1 Solutions
      • Digicloud Africa
      • Digimune
      • Domains.co.za
      • ESET
      • Euphoria Telecom
      • HOSTAFRICA
      • Incredible Business
      • iONLINE
      • IQbusiness
      • Iris Network Systems
      • Kaspersky
      • LSD Open
      • Mitel
      • NEC XON
      • Netstar
      • Network Platforms
      • Next DLP
      • Ovations
      • Paracon
      • Paratus
      • Publishared
      • Q-KON
      • SevenC
      • SkyWire
      • Solid8 Technologies
      • Telit Cinterion
      • Telviva
      • Tenable
      • Vertiv
      • Videri Digital
      • Vodacom Business
      • Vox
      • Wipro
      • Workday
      • XLink
    • Sections
      • AI and machine learning
      • Banking
      • Broadcasting and media
      • Cloud services
      • Contact centres and CX
      • Cryptocurrencies
      • Education and skills
      • Electronics and hardware
      • Energy and sustainability
      • Enterprise software
      • Fintech and payments
      • HealthTech
      • Information security
      • Internet and connectivity
      • Internet of things
      • Investment
      • IT services
      • Lifestyle
      • Policy and regulation
      • Public sector
      • Retail and e-commerce
      • Satellite communications
      • Science
      • SMEs and start-ups
      • Social media
      • Talent and leadership
      • Telecoms
      • Watts & Wheels
    • Events
    • Advertise
    TechCentralTechCentral
    Home » Sections » Telecoms » Stage set for court battle over spectrum pooling

    Stage set for court battle over spectrum pooling

    Vodacom’s spectrum pooling case against Icasa and MTN will soon be heard in the high court in Pretoria.
    By Nkosinathi Ndlovu12 August 2024
    Twitter LinkedIn Facebook WhatsApp Email Telegram Copy Link
    Get breaking news on WhatsApp

    Stage set for court battle over spectrum poolingVodacom’s spectrum pooling case against communications regulator Icasa and telecoms operators MTN, Cell C and Liquid Intelligent Technologies will soon be heard in the high court in Pretoria.

    The matter was initially scheduled to be heard this week — from Tuesday — but TechCentral understands that the parties have agreed at the last minute to a postponement for a case management meeting on 20 August with deputy judge president Aubrey Ledwaba. This meeting will be used to agree on timelines for the hearing and to appoint a judge to hear the matter. This is after some respondents apparently voiced concerns about the schedule.

    TechCentral reported in May that Vodacom had filed an urgent interdict with the court seeking to stop rival MTN from using spectrum pooling arrangements that Vodacom has claimed were unlawfully approved by Icasa in 2022.

    Some of the attempted rebuttals are so obviously strained as to cast focus on the strength of the case for unlawfulness

    In its filing, Vodacom claimed the arrangements, which included one between MTN and Cell C and another between MTN and Liquid, have placed it – as well as Telkom and Rain – at a competitive disadvantage. It suggested this is the principal reason independent tests have shown MTN to have a superior network to its own in recent years.

    Vodacom further alleged that the spectrum pooling deals were approved by Icasa in secret without any public participation as required under the Electronic Communications Act. Telkom, in its own responding affidavit (it is the sixth respondent in the case), agreed with Vodacom’s assertion, saying the secrecy regarding the approvals undermined the regulatory safeguards woven into the spectrum auction process.

    Following Vodacom’s initial filing, responding affidavits by Icasa, MTN, Cell C and Liquid as the first, third, fourth and fifth respondents in the case, respectively, were also filed with the court. Rain, which is listed as the seventh respondent, did not file papers and told TechCentral in response to a query that it is “not involved in the matter”.

    ‘Spurious’

    Prior to going back to court, Vodacom then had the opportunity to file an affidavit in response to the answering affidavits filed by the accused parties. This document, seen by TechCentral, is the basis of the arguments Vodacom will expand on in open court once a hearing date has been confirmed — presumably at or soon after the 20 August meeting.

    One of these arguments is that attempts by the accused parties to refute Vodacom’s claim of illegality have been “spurious” at best, further legitimising the company’s claim.

    “MTN refrains from offering any rebuttal at all of the unlawfulness… This is noteworthy,” said Andrew Barendse, managing executive for regulatory affairs at Vodacom, in the company’s responding affidavit. “Secondly, some of the attempted rebuttals are so obviously strained as to cast focus on the strength of the case for unlawfulness.”

    Read: We are not law breakers: MTN hits back at Vodacom lawsuit

    Vodacom said one of the “most obviously unlawful” aspects of the pooling arrangements was the use of unlicensed and unassigned “guard bands”.

    Guard bands are slivers of spectrum between blocks belonging to different licensees that are deliberately kept empty to minimise interference.

    A portion of Vodacom's head office campus in Midrand, Johannesburg
    A portion of Vodacom’s head office campus in Midrand, Johannesburg

    MTN, in its response filed earlier, downplayed the importance of the guard bands, calling them “archaic” and “small”. Icasa said the matter of guard band abuse, if there was any, should be heard by the regulator’s complaints and compliance committee (CCC); Barendse described this response as “laconic”.

    Barendse held up Vodacom’s initial request that the court should urgently interdict the pooling agreements while it seeks an outcome in the matter, despite arguments against this. Icasa chairman Mothibi Ramusi in his responding affidavit said Vodacom’s application should be struck from the roll due to a “self-created urgency deserving of a punitive cost order”.

    But Barendse flipped the matter on its head, saying Icasa was “evasive” and “lethargic” when queried by Vodacom about the pooling arrangement.

    It is ‘undeniable’ that Vodacom had suffered competitive harm as a result of the pooling arrangements

    ““Vodacom could not rush to the courts without engaging Icasa as the regulator first. Expecting Vodacom to allow the advantaged position of MTN, derived from unlawful approvals, to be entrenched while the process of a review plays itself out in the courts would be unjust and render ultimate success on review potentially nugatory (futile),” said Barendse,” said Barendse.

    He added that it would be “manifestly difficult”, if not impossible, to undo the competitive benefits that MTN, in particular, will continue to gain as a result of the allegedly unlawfully approved pooling arrangements while the matter is still being heard by the courts.

    Barendse said it was “undeniable” that Vodacom had suffered competitive harm as a result of the pooling arrangements. But one of the arguments brought forward by the accused parties is that the agreements are a form of spectrum sharing – which is technically different from spectrum pooling – and provided for within the regulatory framework, they said. Barendse said the name given to the arrangements is not material to determining their illegality.

    Dispute over forum

    “Vodacom’s case for unlawfulness does not depend on this distinction. If the distinction is accepted, then this pooling is something Icasa is not competent to authorise and license, but if the distinction is not accepted, this does not mean sharing can occur without the proper licensing of shared spectrum,” he said.

    When legal proceedings begin, the high court’s take on the argument by Icasa’s Ramusi that the court does not have jurisdiction to hear the matter will be critical for Vodacom’s case. If the court agrees with the regulator, the matter may be struck from the roll.

    Ramusi has argued that Vodacom should have approached the competition authorities – either the Competition Commission or the Competition Tribunal – or the CCC instead of the high court.

    But Barendse said in his affidavit that although the resulting competitive disadvantage was part of Vodacom’s case – and an issue Icasa ought to have examined together with the competition authorities before approving the spectrum pooling arrangements – Vodacom is nonetheless not arguing unlawfulness based on the Competition Act. Rather, it is based on the Electronic Communications Act, where Icasa has purview.

    He said Vodacom could not complain to Icasa and employ Icasa’s complaints procedures in respect of conduct Icasa itself authorised.

    “I note that Icasa asked MTN, Cell C and Liquid for their views on the effects of their proposed arrangement on competition but deny that that constituted a proper competition assessment in terms of the Electronic Communications Act,” said Barendse.  – © 2024 NewsCentral Media

    Read next: Vodacom drags Icasa to court over ‘secret’ spectrum deals

    Add TechCentral as a preferred source on GoogleFollow TechCentral on Google NewsGet breaking news on WhatsApp


    Andrew Barendse Cell C Icasa Liquid Intelligent Technologies Mothibi Ramusi MTN MTN South Africa Rain Vodacom Vodacom South Africa
    WhatsApp YouTube
    Share. Facebook Twitter LinkedIn WhatsApp Telegram Email Copy Link
    Previous ArticleJoburg mall gets Africa’s largest rooftop solar installation
    Next Article China to build vast solar farm in Botswana

    Related Posts

    New tech retailer opens in South Africa, promising to undercut rivals - Amber Dendy Young

    New tech retailer opens in South Africa, promising to undercut rivals

    20 November 2026
    MTN, Telkom and the price of consolidation

    MTN, Telkom and the price of consolidation

    19 November 2026
    Icasa to fight Sakeliga's court bid over 30% ownership rule

    Icasa to fight Sakeliga’s court bid over 30% ownership rule

    19 November 2026
    Company News
    2027: the year ID documents stop being enough

    2027: the year ID documents stop being enough

    19 November 2026
    Why banks' digital channels still leave customers stuck - BBD Software

    Why banks’ digital channels still leave customers stuck

    19 November 2026
    Q-Day is coming. Is your business ready? - Antony Russell, Telviva

    Q-Day is coming. Is your business ready?

    19 November 2026
    Opinion
    Icasa's Sim rules need a privacy backstop - Lloyd Matthew and Heinz Vollmer

    Icasa’s Sim rules need a privacy backstop

    5 November 2026
    AI's boardroom honeymoon is over - Gary Stocks

    AI’s boardroom honeymoon is over

    22 October 2026
    Before South Africa licenses Starlink, it should look at Ukraine - Duncan McLeod

    Before South Africa licenses Starlink, it should look at Ukraine

    21 October 2026

    Subscribe to Updates

    Get the best South African technology news and analysis delivered to your e-mail inbox every morning.

    Latest Posts
    New tech retailer opens in South Africa, promising to undercut rivals - Amber Dendy Young

    New tech retailer opens in South Africa, promising to undercut rivals

    20 November 2026
    Meet the CIO | Wits's Stanley Mpofu on taking campus Wi-Fi to malls and libraries

    Meet the CIO | Wits’s Stanley Mpofu on taking campus Wi-Fi to malls and libraries

    20 November 2026
    Caby takes on Uber and Bolt in Cape Town - Denise Walker

    Caby takes on Uber and Bolt in Cape Town

    20 November 2026
    Tencent props up Naspers as iFood and Just Eat spending bites - Fabricio Bloisi

    Tencent props up Naspers as iFood and Just Eat spending bites

    20 November 2026
    © 2009 - 2026 NewsCentral Media
    Built and maintained by Chronon
    • Cookie policy (ZA)
    • TechCentral – privacy and Popia

    Type above and press Enter to search. Press Esc to cancel.

    Manage consent

    TechCentral uses cookies to enhance its offerings. Consenting to these technologies allows us to serve you better. Not consenting or withdrawing consent may adversely affect certain features and functions of the website.

    Functional Always active
    The technical storage or access is strictly necessary for the legitimate purpose of enabling the use of a specific service explicitly requested by the subscriber or user, or for the sole purpose of carrying out the transmission of a communication over an electronic communications network.
    Preferences
    The technical storage or access is necessary for the legitimate purpose of storing preferences that are not requested by the subscriber or user.
    Statistics
    The technical storage or access that is used exclusively for statistical purposes. The technical storage or access that is used exclusively for anonymous statistical purposes. Without a subpoena, voluntary compliance on the part of your Internet Service Provider, or additional records from a third party, information stored or retrieved for this purpose alone cannot usually be used to identify you.
    Marketing
    The technical storage or access is required to create user profiles to send advertising, or to track the user on a website or across several websites for similar marketing purposes.
    • Manage options
    • Manage services
    • Manage {vendor_count} vendors
    • Read more about these purposes
    View preferences
    • {title}
    • {title}
    • {title}
    🇿🇦 Sign up to the TechCentral newsletter