Close Menu
TechCentralTechCentral

    Subscribe to the newsletter

    Get the best South African technology news and analysis delivered to your e-mail inbox every morning.

    Facebook X (Twitter) YouTube LinkedIn
    WhatsApp Facebook X (Twitter) LinkedIn YouTube
    TechCentralTechCentral
    • News
      MTN, Telkom and the price of consolidation

      MTN, Telkom and the price of consolidation

      19 November 2026
      Icasa to fight Sakeliga's court bid over 30% ownership rule

      Icasa to fight Sakeliga’s court bid over 30% ownership rule

      19 November 2026
      President Cyril Ramaphosa

      Ramaphosa pitches ageing power stations as AI data centre sites

      19 November 2026
      Workday puts its AI agents on a leash - Aneel Bhusri

      Workday puts its AI agents on a leash

      19 November 2026
      Takealot adds Spotify to its answer to Amazon Prime

      Takealot adds Spotify to its answer to Amazon Prime

      19 November 2026
    • World
      Critical Java bug could let hackers take over servers

      Critical Java bug could let hackers take over servers

      19 November 2026
      Nvidia shuts the door on a Jensen Huang comeback

      Nvidia shuts the door on a Jensen Huang comeback

      17 November 2026
      Could Jensen Huang return to Nvidia?

      Jensen Huang weighs a comeback at Nvidia

      16 November 2026
      Intel sued by shareholders over 29% share price plunge - Intel CEO Lip-Bu Tan. Laure Andrillon/Reuters

      Intel sued by shareholders over 29% share price plunge

      16 November 2026
      Microsoft 364

      Microsoft outage hits the world

      13 November 2026
    • In-depth
      Inside the 24 hours that broke Microsoft

      Inside the 24 hours that broke Microsoft

      16 November 2026
      Ducking hell: inside Apple's hidden list of words the iPhone won't suggest

      Ducking hell: inside Apple’s hidden list of words the iPhone won’t suggest

      6 November 2026
      Why investors are souring on Netflix

      Why investors are souring on Netflix

      22 October 2026

      10 days that changed the course of AI

      21 September 2026
      Meta to the AI industry: slow down without us - Mark Zuckerberg

      Meta to the AI industry: slow down without us

      16 September 2026
    • TCS
      TCS | Piet le Roux on Sakeliga's fight with Icasa over BEE

      TCS | Piet le Roux on Sakeliga’s fight with Icasa over BEE

      13 November 2026
      W&W | The AA’s Bobby Ramagwede on a car industry running out of road

      W&W | The AA’s Bobby Ramagwede on a car industry running out of road

      12 November 2026
      TCS | Pick n Pay fights back in online grocery wars - Vince Viviers

      TCS | Pick n Pay fights back in online grocery wars

      11 November 2026
      TCS | Nomvuyiso Batyi on the battle over Sim registration - Nomvuyiso Batyi

      TCS | Nomvuyiso Batyi on the battle over Sim registration

      9 November 2026
      TCS+ | Old Mutual's Celiwe Ross on leading people through AI - Old Mutual

      TCS+ | Old Mutual’s Celiwe Ross on leading people through AI

      6 November 2026
    • Opinion
      Icasa's Sim rules need a privacy backstop - Lloyd Matthew and Heinz Vollmer

      Icasa’s Sim rules need a privacy backstop

      5 November 2026
      AI's boardroom honeymoon is over - Gary Stocks

      AI’s boardroom honeymoon is over

      22 October 2026
      Before South Africa licenses Starlink, it should look at Ukraine - Duncan McLeod

      Before South Africa licenses Starlink, it should look at Ukraine

      21 October 2026
      Nonkqubela Thathakahle Jordan-Dyani

      Why cybersecurity is now a national security issue for South Africa

      15 October 2026
      When a machine can choose, who does it become? Fanie van Rooyen

      When a machine can choose, who does it become?

      9 October 2026
    • Company News
      • 1Stream
      • Africa Data Centres
      • AfriGIS
      • Altron Digital Business
      • Altron Document Solutions
      • Altron Group
      • Arctic Wolf
      • Ascent Technology
      • AvertITD
      • BBD
      • Braintree
      • CallMiner
      • CambriLearn
      • CM.com
      • Contactable
      • CYBER1 Solutions
      • Digicloud Africa
      • Digimune
      • Domains.co.za
      • ESET
      • Euphoria Telecom
      • HOSTAFRICA
      • Incredible Business
      • iONLINE
      • IQbusiness
      • Iris Network Systems
      • Kaspersky
      • LSD Open
      • Mitel
      • NEC XON
      • Netstar
      • Network Platforms
      • Next DLP
      • Ovations
      • Paracon
      • Paratus
      • Publishared
      • Q-KON
      • SevenC
      • SkyWire
      • Solid8 Technologies
      • Telit Cinterion
      • Telviva
      • Tenable
      • Vertiv
      • Videri Digital
      • Vodacom Business
      • Vox
      • Wipro
      • Workday
      • XLink
    • Sections
      • AI and machine learning
      • Banking
      • Broadcasting and media
      • Cloud services
      • Contact centres and CX
      • Cryptocurrencies
      • Education and skills
      • Electronics and hardware
      • Energy and sustainability
      • Enterprise software
      • Fintech and payments
      • HealthTech
      • Information security
      • Internet and connectivity
      • Internet of things
      • Investment
      • IT services
      • Lifestyle
      • Policy and regulation
      • Public sector
      • Retail and e-commerce
      • Satellite communications
      • Science
      • SMEs and start-ups
      • Social media
      • Talent and leadership
      • Telecoms
      • Watts & Wheels
    • Events
    • Advertise
    TechCentralTechCentral
    Home » In-depth » Dear David Cameron…

    Dear David Cameron…

    By The Conversation9 February 2015
    Twitter LinkedIn Facebook WhatsApp Email Telegram Copy Link
    Get breaking news on WhatsApp

    David Cameron
    David Cameron

    Dear Mr Cameron,

    You recently proposed that all Internet apps — and their users’ communications — be compelled to make themselves accessible to state authorities. I want to explain why this is a very bad idea even though it might seem like a no-brainer.

    You said:

    “I have a very simple principle which will be the heart of the new legislation that will be necessary. In our country, do we want to allow a means of communication between people which even in extremis, with a signed warrant from the home secretary personally, that we cannot read? Up until now, governments have said: ‘No, we must not’.
    That is why in extremis it has been possible to read someone’s letter, to listen to someone’s telephone, to mobile communications. …
    But the question is: are we going to allow a means of communications which it simply isn’t possible to read. My answer to that question is: ‘No we must not’.”

    US President Barack Obama appears to agree with you.

    Heads of government bear the burden of keeping their citizens safe. That’s a crushing responsibility. Police solve violent crimes — and intelligence agencies predict and avert them — in significant part by intercepting the conversations of people conspiring to get away with them.

    For at least 50 years, democracies have kept eavesdropping within bounds by requiring a warrant or some other form of meaningful review before doing it. As telephone companies upgraded to digital (but still not Internet-based) networks in the 1990s, governments around the world began to require that the new networks still allow for authorities to listen in to calls.

    The rationale was simple and generally uncontroversial: as long as the government respected the rule of law, its demands for information shouldn’t be trumped by new technological facts on the ground.

    Why, then, you reasonably ask, should that long-established balance between security and privacy be disturbed simply because the Internet has replaced telephony?

    The answer, it turns out, is that baking government access into all Internet apps will, in fact, not extend the long-established balance between security and privacy to all mediums of communication. It will upend it.

    First, the landscape of Internet communications services is profoundly different from telephony, where lawful intercept’s habits were honed.

    Traditional telephone systems were run by a single large company or by governments themselves. They overwhelmingly served the single purpose of letting people talk to each other at a distance and the experience of using a phone in 1990 was little different from that of using one in 1950.

    Supporting lawful eavesdropping was done with no impact on telephony’s basic model — and often governments would pay to offset any costs incurred in keeping phone lines open to tapping.

    The Internet evolved in a wildly different way. It supports applications written by anyone, and a new application can become popular in a heartbeat. Some people write and share apps for fun rather than money.

    To restrict how one might build an Internet application that enables person-to-person communication — that is, nearly all of the hundreds of thousands of apps out there — would require software developers to hire compliance attorneys or risk breaking the law.

    In the worst-case scenario, software development would be relegated to a handful of incumbents ready to do the kind of partnerships with governments that sophisticated phone companies do. Facebook, Google and Microsoft could cope (if unhappily), but software authors and service providers the next tier down would be hugely disadvantaged.

    In the best-case scenario, to give government broad access, app authors across the spectrum would face having to orchestrate a complex scheme of scrambling or encrypting to all but restricted parties and the government. They would likely give up on encryption entirely, which would be a nightmare for the public’s — and therefore national — security as it would expose communications to anyone ready to hack.

    Lawful telephone eavesdropping wouldn’t have come about if that meant it would be easy for others — even at a distance — to also listen in on a conversation.

    Users now have choice
    Second, regulating apps so comprehensively is either self-defeatingly leaky or unacceptably intrusive. Unlike telephony, Internet users who don’t like the way an app works can choose to use another.

    As a practical matter, WhatsApp, owned by Facebook, could — under your legislation — successfully be required to change the way it encrypts users’ communications. Since Facebook can’t readily gainsay what a major government wants and since Facebook has “boots on the ground” in London, it can be easily tracked down and it has to comply with government demands.

    So, you may be looking at large companies like Facebook and thinking that regulation will be easy, without considering the millions of other sources of code produced by fiercely independent and often anonymous developers who are based in the UK.

    Despite WhatsApp’s US$19bn price tag, its basic functionality could be reproduced in a weekend by two caffeine-fuelled university students. The speed with which the public could migrate to a new coder’s NextApp would up the stakes for the massive enforcement you’d have to conduct for your proposed requirement have any impact.

    Indeed, you’d have to constrain the application ecosystem itself by further requiring that new code be vetted before it can be installed on people’s platforms.

    That would accelerate a profound and undesirable flip from software that flows freely except in the most unusual of circumstances to software that can only move once it meets government standards. PCs would have to become like iPhones, running only what their originators — Microsoft and Apple — permit.

    Seriously, this isn’t just about telling BT Group to go ahead and tweak its software. Rather, it would position a handful of companies as gatekeepers to the vast and colourful universe of code that flows from millions of sources. And these gatekeepers would turn out to be the very companies whose market dominance has so deeply troubled European authorities.

    Empowering the lawless
    A here’s the third problem: a requirement to make encryption breakable by the prevailing legal authority would be a gift to states that do not embrace the rule of law.

    Billions of people live in such countries and Western technology has represented one of their best shots at the freedom to communicate enshrined as a universal human right. Their governments have had to invest enormous amounts of effort to extract the economic benefits of being connected to the rest of the world while still enforcing censorship and surveillance.

    If you succeed in shaping our software so that we can’t keep secrets from authorities bearing valid warrants, you will also make it so that people can’t keep secrets from regimes who don’t bother with warrants.

    All of these reasons are grounded in the fundamentals of the way the Internet has evolved, not to mention the nearly unthinkable costs of trying to push it to a place where communications could be monitored across all Internet applications.

    Finally, building systems to secure communications against all but the communicating parties and the government is really, really difficult, and entails its own risk of catastrophic failure, rendering communications worse off than if they hadn’t been encrypted at all.

    I understand the imperative to provide security. I also understand that it makes sense to determine the boundary between state and citizen through democratically enacted, constitutionally sound law rather than the cat-and-mouse behaviour between technological hacks and counter hacks. Unfortunately, that is the kind of behaviour that this proposal would foster.

    In an age where ever more sophisticated encryption becomes available, it can seem that entire sectors of communications that were once regularly monitored are “going dark”. But a simple technological mandate to prevent the use of strong encryption is not, in fact, simple.

    The toolkit for law enforcement and intelligence agencies to do their necessary work is deep and growing. The fact that some apps encrypt need not stymie investigations of large-scale terrorism.

    Mr Cameron, I do not envy you your job. The only solace is that the choice this proposal represents is, in fact, an easy one: don’t attempt it.

    The Internet has been a force for modernity and openness — exactly what those who believe in indiscriminate violence despise. Let’s not try to build them a network that they find more agreeable, in the name of the short-term imperative to uncover and prevent their worst.The Conversation

    Regards,
    Jonathan Zittrain

    • Zittrain is George Bemis professor of law and professor of computer science at Harvard University
    • This article was originally published on The Conversation
    Add TechCentral as a preferred source on GoogleFollow TechCentral on Google NewsGet breaking news on WhatsApp


    Barack Obama David Cameron Jonathan Zittrain
    WhatsApp YouTube
    Share. Facebook Twitter LinkedIn WhatsApp Telegram Email Copy Link
    Previous ArticleAdapt IT earnings rise 35%
    Next Article New CEO at Seacom

    Related Posts

    Beware the digital demagogues

    Beware the digital demagogues

    19 August 2024

    Politicians are cashing in on the tech boom

    16 April 2021

    A hack like this could start the next World War

    8 March 2021
    Company News
    2027: the year ID documents stop being enough

    2027: the year ID documents stop being enough

    19 November 2026
    Why banks' digital channels still leave customers stuck - BBD Software

    Why banks’ digital channels still leave customers stuck

    19 November 2026
    Q-Day is coming. Is your business ready? - Antony Russell, Telviva

    Q-Day is coming. Is your business ready?

    19 November 2026
    Opinion
    Icasa's Sim rules need a privacy backstop - Lloyd Matthew and Heinz Vollmer

    Icasa’s Sim rules need a privacy backstop

    5 November 2026
    AI's boardroom honeymoon is over - Gary Stocks

    AI’s boardroom honeymoon is over

    22 October 2026
    Before South Africa licenses Starlink, it should look at Ukraine - Duncan McLeod

    Before South Africa licenses Starlink, it should look at Ukraine

    21 October 2026

    Subscribe to Updates

    Get the best South African technology news and analysis delivered to your e-mail inbox every morning.

    Latest Posts
    MTN, Telkom and the price of consolidation

    MTN, Telkom and the price of consolidation

    19 November 2026
    Icasa to fight Sakeliga's court bid over 30% ownership rule

    Icasa to fight Sakeliga’s court bid over 30% ownership rule

    19 November 2026
    President Cyril Ramaphosa

    Ramaphosa pitches ageing power stations as AI data centre sites

    19 November 2026
    Workday puts its AI agents on a leash - Aneel Bhusri

    Workday puts its AI agents on a leash

    19 November 2026
    © 2009 - 2026 NewsCentral Media
    Built and maintained by Chronon
    • Cookie policy (ZA)
    • TechCentral – privacy and Popia

    Type above and press Enter to search. Press Esc to cancel.

    Manage consent

    TechCentral uses cookies to enhance its offerings. Consenting to these technologies allows us to serve you better. Not consenting or withdrawing consent may adversely affect certain features and functions of the website.

    Functional Always active
    The technical storage or access is strictly necessary for the legitimate purpose of enabling the use of a specific service explicitly requested by the subscriber or user, or for the sole purpose of carrying out the transmission of a communication over an electronic communications network.
    Preferences
    The technical storage or access is necessary for the legitimate purpose of storing preferences that are not requested by the subscriber or user.
    Statistics
    The technical storage or access that is used exclusively for statistical purposes. The technical storage or access that is used exclusively for anonymous statistical purposes. Without a subpoena, voluntary compliance on the part of your Internet Service Provider, or additional records from a third party, information stored or retrieved for this purpose alone cannot usually be used to identify you.
    Marketing
    The technical storage or access is required to create user profiles to send advertising, or to track the user on a website or across several websites for similar marketing purposes.
    • Manage options
    • Manage services
    • Manage {vendor_count} vendors
    • Read more about these purposes
    View preferences
    • {title}
    • {title}
    • {title}
    🇿🇦 Sign up to the TechCentral newsletter