Set-top box move is 'good news' - TechCentral

Set-top box move is ‘good news’

The Democratic Alliance welcomes the news that the procurement process for the government-sponsored set-top boxes is being reviewed because of an irregular procurement process and unaffordability of the project.

This was confirmed in Tuesday’s meetings of the portfolio committee on telecommunications & postal services by the CEO of the Universal Service & Access Agency of South Africa (Usaasa) Lumka Mtimde. Usaasa is the government entity responsible for the procurement process of the set-top boxes.

Mtimde was responding to the DA’s question about what information he had on media reports stating that the new communications minister, Ayanda Dlodlo, was contemplating reverting to the pre-March 2015 broadcasting digital migration policy that enabled signal encryption on the boxes. Dlodlo also confirmed the reports on the new policy in the communications committee on Tuesday.

This policy is currently before the constitutional court to rule on whether previous communications minister, Faith Muthambi, followed the correct procedure in revising the policy, which had been developed in line with ANC policy and subjected to rigorous public engagement. Muthambi’s action and subsequent legal challenges have delayed the roll-out of set-top boxes by two years.

The roll-out was aggravated by the fact that the first orders for 1,5m boxes that were issued by Usaasa in August 2015 in a process that is deemed to be riddled with irregularities and probable illegalities. The new management of Usaasa halted production of these boxes when legal challenges to Muthambi’s migration policy cast doubt on their technical specifications.

Mtimde told the committee that the government entities involved in the migration project met this past weekend with Dlodlo and telecoms & postal services minister Siyabonga Cwele for an update and discussion on how to fast-track the process.

While unable to give specifics of the conversations, Mtimde said the procurement process was being reviewed in light of there being limited funds from national treasury to proceed with the current procurement and the auditor-general’s findings on the irregularities of the issue.

Mtimde made no mention of the PricewaterhouseCoopers investigation, commissioned by national treasury, that was delivered to Muthambi last March. Portions of it were published on the department of communications website and clearly showed irregular processes were followed. Muthambi failed to respond to the DA’s Promotion of Access to Information Act request for the full report.

Last year, the DA called on the portfolio chairpersons of both communications and telecoms & postal services to host a two-day public hearing into whether the set-top box programme was still technologically relevant and affordable, and to review the seemingly corrupt tender process.

A joint meeting of the two committees to get an update of the digital terrestrial broadcasting migration project is scheduled for 6 June.

The International Telecommunication Union’s international deadline for switching off the analogue broadcast signals to make way for the airwaves to exploit digital technology for wireless broadband services as well as audio and digital broadcasting was 15 June 2015. South Africa is still listed on the ITU website as not having started.

  • Marian Shinn is an MP for the Democratic Alliance and the party’s spokeswoman of telecoms & postal services


  1. Andrew Fraser on

    I’m still not sure why the DA is supporting encryption on these STBs. It is incredibly short-sighted.

  2. Angus Clarke on

    Sorry, but you are totally out of the loop. It’s the correct way forward to allow all broadcasters access to some of the best material that FTF Broadcasters normally cannot access. Also Govt can make use of encryption services to ensure that they can have strategic meetings around the country on a Private network without unwanted people joining in & saving a fortune on traveling & accommodation.

  3. Andrew Fraser on

    Actually you’ve just drunk the e. TV Kool Aid.

    1. Encryption is not a requirement for FTA broadcasters, and I can point you to some major FTA digital broadcasters in Europe to prove that. Copy protection is the only protection that content owners specify – and that is included in the HDMI specification.

    2. How exactly are these government folk going to use a one-many broadcast solution to have private meetings? You do know that meetings require a return path, right? Also, if government or anyone else wants to have encryption, they’re welcome to do it. It just shouldn’t be mandatory in the set-top box that is being subsidised by the taxpayer. Encryption adds complexity and cost to the box and means that South Africa will be stuck in a technological backwater because there will be no incentive to improve the decoders or to offer advanced features of the DVB-T2 system.

    So, with respect, with my 15 years plus of experience in TV plus an ongoing interest in the clusterfxck of a digital migration over the past 10 years, I’d say that I’m definitely not “totally out of the loop”.

  4. Vusumuzi Sibiya on

    The time for the DA to reshuffle certain shadow ministers is long over due.

© 2009 – 2019 NewsCentral Media