Close Menu
TechCentralTechCentral

    Subscribe to the newsletter

    Get the best South African technology news and analysis delivered to your e-mail inbox every morning.

    Facebook X (Twitter) YouTube LinkedIn
    WhatsApp Facebook X (Twitter) LinkedIn YouTube
    TechCentralTechCentral
    • News
      New tech retailer opens in South Africa, promising to undercut rivals - Amber Dendy Young

      New tech retailer opens in South Africa, promising to undercut rivals

      20 November 2026
      Meet the CIO | Wits's Stanley Mpofu on taking campus Wi-Fi to malls and libraries

      Meet the CIO | Wits’s Stanley Mpofu on taking campus Wi-Fi to malls and libraries

      20 November 2026
      Caby takes on Uber and Bolt in Cape Town - Denise Walker

      Caby takes on Uber and Bolt in Cape Town

      20 November 2026
      Tencent props up Naspers as iFood and Just Eat spending bites - Fabricio Bloisi

      Tencent props up Naspers as iFood and Just Eat spending bites

      20 November 2026
      MTN, Telkom and the price of consolidation

      MTN, Telkom and the price of consolidation

      19 November 2026
    • World
      Critical Java bug could let hackers take over servers

      Critical Java bug could let hackers take over servers

      19 November 2026
      Nvidia shuts the door on a Jensen Huang comeback

      Nvidia shuts the door on a Jensen Huang comeback

      17 November 2026
      Could Jensen Huang return to Nvidia?

      Jensen Huang weighs a comeback at Nvidia

      16 November 2026
      Intel sued by shareholders over 29% share price plunge - Intel CEO Lip-Bu Tan. Laure Andrillon/Reuters

      Intel sued by shareholders over 29% share price plunge

      16 November 2026
      Microsoft 364

      Microsoft outage hits the world

      13 November 2026
    • In-depth
      Inside the 24 hours that broke Microsoft

      Inside the 24 hours that broke Microsoft

      16 November 2026
      Ducking hell: inside Apple's hidden list of words the iPhone won't suggest

      Ducking hell: inside Apple’s hidden list of words the iPhone won’t suggest

      6 November 2026
      Why investors are souring on Netflix

      Why investors are souring on Netflix

      22 October 2026

      10 days that changed the course of AI

      21 September 2026
      Meta to the AI industry: slow down without us - Mark Zuckerberg

      Meta to the AI industry: slow down without us

      16 September 2026
    • TCS
      TCS | Piet le Roux on Sakeliga's fight with Icasa over BEE

      TCS | Piet le Roux on Sakeliga’s fight with Icasa over BEE

      13 November 2026
      W&W | The AA’s Bobby Ramagwede on a car industry running out of road

      W&W | The AA’s Bobby Ramagwede on a car industry running out of road

      12 November 2026
      TCS | Pick n Pay fights back in online grocery wars - Vince Viviers

      TCS | Pick n Pay fights back in online grocery wars

      11 November 2026
      TCS | Nomvuyiso Batyi on the battle over Sim registration - Nomvuyiso Batyi

      TCS | Nomvuyiso Batyi on the battle over Sim registration

      9 November 2026
      TCS+ | Old Mutual's Celiwe Ross on leading people through AI - Old Mutual

      TCS+ | Old Mutual’s Celiwe Ross on leading people through AI

      6 November 2026
    • Opinion
      Icasa's Sim rules need a privacy backstop - Lloyd Matthew and Heinz Vollmer

      Icasa’s Sim rules need a privacy backstop

      5 November 2026
      AI's boardroom honeymoon is over - Gary Stocks

      AI’s boardroom honeymoon is over

      22 October 2026
      Before South Africa licenses Starlink, it should look at Ukraine - Duncan McLeod

      Before South Africa licenses Starlink, it should look at Ukraine

      21 October 2026
      Nonkqubela Thathakahle Jordan-Dyani

      Why cybersecurity is now a national security issue for South Africa

      15 October 2026
      When a machine can choose, who does it become? Fanie van Rooyen

      When a machine can choose, who does it become?

      9 October 2026
    • Company News
      • 1Stream
      • Africa Data Centres
      • AfriGIS
      • Altron Digital Business
      • Altron Document Solutions
      • Altron Group
      • Arctic Wolf
      • Ascent Technology
      • AvertITD
      • BBD
      • Braintree
      • CallMiner
      • CambriLearn
      • CM.com
      • Contactable
      • CYBER1 Solutions
      • Digicloud Africa
      • Digimune
      • Domains.co.za
      • ESET
      • Euphoria Telecom
      • HOSTAFRICA
      • Incredible Business
      • iONLINE
      • IQbusiness
      • Iris Network Systems
      • Kaspersky
      • LSD Open
      • Mitel
      • NEC XON
      • Netstar
      • Network Platforms
      • Next DLP
      • Ovations
      • Paracon
      • Paratus
      • Publishared
      • Q-KON
      • SevenC
      • SkyWire
      • Solid8 Technologies
      • Telit Cinterion
      • Telviva
      • Tenable
      • Vertiv
      • Videri Digital
      • Vodacom Business
      • Vox
      • Wipro
      • Workday
      • XLink
    • Sections
      • AI and machine learning
      • Banking
      • Broadcasting and media
      • Cloud services
      • Contact centres and CX
      • Cryptocurrencies
      • Education and skills
      • Electronics and hardware
      • Energy and sustainability
      • Enterprise software
      • Fintech and payments
      • HealthTech
      • Information security
      • Internet and connectivity
      • Internet of things
      • Investment
      • IT services
      • Lifestyle
      • Policy and regulation
      • Public sector
      • Retail and e-commerce
      • Satellite communications
      • Science
      • SMEs and start-ups
      • Social media
      • Talent and leadership
      • Telecoms
      • Watts & Wheels
    • Events
    • Advertise
    TechCentralTechCentral
    Home » World » How to tackle tech giants’ growing dominance

    How to tackle tech giants’ growing dominance

    By Leonid Bershidsky11 September 2017
    Twitter LinkedIn Facebook WhatsApp Email Telegram Copy Link
    Get breaking news on WhatsApp

    People in the US, not just in the European Union, are finally getting worried about tech sector leaders’ market dominance and the political power it confers. Unfortunately, the solutions gaining traction are the kind of anti-monopoly regulations that address the symptoms of the problem, not its root cause.

    Some 45% of American adults get news from Facebook. Google’s search market share in the US approaches 86%. About 43% of all online retail sales in the US last year went through Amazon. So no wonder people get concerned when Facebook reports that, during the US presidential campaign, hundreds of fake accounts, possibly operated from Russia, bought and ran about US$100 000 worth of political ads from the social media company. It’s no surprise that there’s an outcry about Google’s treatment of free speech inside the company and, likely, in a think tank the company funds. It’s natural that Amazon’s Whole Foods acquisition raises alarms.

    The fundamental problem with the tech leaders is that they have, for many years, succeeded in presenting themselves as something different than they are

    How can these benign, universally loved innovators be stopped from turning into evil, soulless corporate behemoths? Break up companies such as Facebook, Google and Amazon, some say, or at least stop them from buying up companies that allow them to consolidate their dominance. Or perhaps recognise them as utilities — the approach advocated by Barry Lynn, head of the Open Markets programme cut loose by the New America think tank after Google executive chairman Eric Schmidt complained about Lynn’s work. The catch-all name for all the proposals, popularised by George Mason University law professor Joshua Wright, is “hipster antitrust”.

    Neither makes sense in most cases. The European Union’s antitrust commissioner Margrethe Vestager has only got involved with the US tech giants because European monopoly and state aid law provided some relatively low-hanging fruit. That doesn’t mean US regulation should follow the European path of least resistance. Besides, the case for increasing the regulation of some companies is better than for others.

    A big retailer

    The fundamental problem with the tech leaders is that they have, for many years, succeeded in presenting themselves as something different than they are. Amazon (minus its commercial cloud business) is a big retailer with a strong distribution network that other retailers also choose to use. Google and Facebook are media corporations because their business model, based on selling ads, puts them squarely in that sector; it doesn’t matter that they don’t themselves create the content they sell to advertisers or that they collect lots of behavioral data about users — the money-for-eyeballs model remains essentially the same as for old-school media companies. Uber is a taxi firm. Airbnb is a hospitality company.

    As Robert Haslehurst and Alan Lewis of LEK Consulting wrote in the Harvard Business Review last year, a market is only new if the transaction that occurs in it didn’t previously exist; thus, cellular communications constituted a new market when they were first offered to consumers. But Amazon, Uber, Airbnb, and even Google and Facebook don’t, as a rule, offer such fundamentally new transactions. “We believe,” Haslehurst and Lewis wrote, “that these businesses have not redefined industries in a fundamental way; instead they are ‘old wines in new bottles’. They have more similarities than differences with traditional businesses, and should be regulated accordingly.”

    The Silicon Valley firms have managed to convince regulators that they are something completely new — platform companies that enable the transfer of goods and services. European regulators have swallowed this concept whole and are trying to define what is permissible for platforms and what’s not. The argument for defining the firms as utilities, as well as the calls for Facebook and Google to maintain political neutrality, also come from this idea of “platforms”: if the companies are merely facilitators and marketplaces, they should treat everything and everyone using them exactly the same.

    This is an approach that could, in theory, eventually lead to the break-up of Amazon into a retail company and an eBay-like online marketplace company that also offers logistics and delivery services. It has already spawned, for example, an Indian law passed last year that only allows 100% foreign ownership of companies that operate mainly as a marketplace, with no more than 25% of their sales coming from one vendor, such as the company itself. It could also limit Google’s ability to offer certain services that others advertise on its “platform” — the next step after this year’s European Commission ruling that it stop prioritising its own shopping comparison service over others.

    If it is recognised that Facebook is a media company, it will be legally liable for its content, and it will be forced to keep better track of fraudulent anonymous usage

    This, however, is also an approach that will change little for consumers or for governments in countries where these US behemoths operate but pay almost no taxes. Today, consumers aren’t really being price-gouged by Amazon — quite the contrary, they often prefer it to bricks-and-mortar stores because it offers lower prices. Nor do consumers suffer from Google’s comparison-shopping service. They might suffer someday if the companies become more dominant and, at the same time, greedier. But there’s no point in trying to fix a nonexistent problem now.

    The current problem is that, under the mantle of innovation, the companies are avoiding the strenuous regulation that their more traditional rivals have to accept. The tax schemes used by Google and Amazon allow them to pay little tax in Europe by paying large intellectual property royalties to firms in offshore areas. No “legacy” retailer or media company would be allowed to pay most of its profit to a Caribbean shell company holding the rights to a distribution scheme or an ad-selling technique. It shouldn’t be allowed to “tech” companies either; otherwise, the playing field is not level and older rivals have less resources to invest in new technology to compete more effectively. This is not really about antitrust, though state aid laws in Europe are the purview of competition authorities; this is about closing obvious, well-known tax loopholes.

    Not too late

    Treating the “platforms” as they really are would even the playing field in other ways, too. If it is recognised that Facebook is a media company, it will be legally liable for its content, and it will be forced to keep better track of fraudulent anonymous usage, like US political ads placed by foreign customers. A “legacy” media company always know who has bought ads, sometimes after vetting by the legal department. Using a different ad-placement technology shouldn’t absolve Facebook, or Google, from this kind of responsibility. It shouldn’t worry regulators how the companies are going to enforce content control, just as it doesn’t worry them in the case of a traditional publisher or TV channel. The firms will just have to figure out how to do it — and they will be free to have an overt editorial policy, as media companies do.

    It would benefit vigorous competition if Uber had to submit to all the transport regulations followed by its rivals. Subjecting Airbnb to hotel regulations would put it on a more equal footing with hotel chains that use essentially the same “asset-light” approach, owning few of their properties.

    It’s rather late but not too late to apply existing rules to these companies. Once that happens, competitors may start catching up in markets from media to retail, from urban transportation to hospitality, and the current “platforms'” size may cease to be such an irritant.  — (c) 2017 Bloomberg LP

    Add TechCentral as a preferred source on GoogleFollow TechCentral on Google NewsGet breaking news on WhatsApp


    Airbnb Amazon Facebook Google Leonid Bershidsky Margrethe Vestager top Uber
    WhatsApp YouTube
    Share. Facebook Twitter LinkedIn WhatsApp Telegram Email Copy Link
    Previous ArticleControl structure ensures continuity: Naspers
    Next Article Cars becoming like phones, needing regular software updates

    Related Posts

    Caby takes on Uber and Bolt in Cape Town - Denise Walker

    Caby takes on Uber and Bolt in Cape Town

    20 November 2026
    Workday puts its AI agents on a leash - Aneel Bhusri

    Workday puts its AI agents on a leash

    19 November 2026
    Takealot adds Spotify to its answer to Amazon Prime

    Takealot adds Spotify to its answer to Amazon Prime

    19 November 2026
    Company News
    2027: the year ID documents stop being enough

    2027: the year ID documents stop being enough

    19 November 2026
    Why banks' digital channels still leave customers stuck - BBD Software

    Why banks’ digital channels still leave customers stuck

    19 November 2026
    Q-Day is coming. Is your business ready? - Antony Russell, Telviva

    Q-Day is coming. Is your business ready?

    19 November 2026
    Opinion
    Icasa's Sim rules need a privacy backstop - Lloyd Matthew and Heinz Vollmer

    Icasa’s Sim rules need a privacy backstop

    5 November 2026
    AI's boardroom honeymoon is over - Gary Stocks

    AI’s boardroom honeymoon is over

    22 October 2026
    Before South Africa licenses Starlink, it should look at Ukraine - Duncan McLeod

    Before South Africa licenses Starlink, it should look at Ukraine

    21 October 2026

    Subscribe to Updates

    Get the best South African technology news and analysis delivered to your e-mail inbox every morning.

    Latest Posts
    New tech retailer opens in South Africa, promising to undercut rivals - Amber Dendy Young

    New tech retailer opens in South Africa, promising to undercut rivals

    20 November 2026
    Meet the CIO | Wits's Stanley Mpofu on taking campus Wi-Fi to malls and libraries

    Meet the CIO | Wits’s Stanley Mpofu on taking campus Wi-Fi to malls and libraries

    20 November 2026
    Caby takes on Uber and Bolt in Cape Town - Denise Walker

    Caby takes on Uber and Bolt in Cape Town

    20 November 2026
    Tencent props up Naspers as iFood and Just Eat spending bites - Fabricio Bloisi

    Tencent props up Naspers as iFood and Just Eat spending bites

    20 November 2026
    © 2009 - 2026 NewsCentral Media
    Built and maintained by Chronon
    • Cookie policy (ZA)
    • TechCentral – privacy and Popia

    Type above and press Enter to search. Press Esc to cancel.

    Manage consent

    TechCentral uses cookies to enhance its offerings. Consenting to these technologies allows us to serve you better. Not consenting or withdrawing consent may adversely affect certain features and functions of the website.

    Functional Always active
    The technical storage or access is strictly necessary for the legitimate purpose of enabling the use of a specific service explicitly requested by the subscriber or user, or for the sole purpose of carrying out the transmission of a communication over an electronic communications network.
    Preferences
    The technical storage or access is necessary for the legitimate purpose of storing preferences that are not requested by the subscriber or user.
    Statistics
    The technical storage or access that is used exclusively for statistical purposes. The technical storage or access that is used exclusively for anonymous statistical purposes. Without a subpoena, voluntary compliance on the part of your Internet Service Provider, or additional records from a third party, information stored or retrieved for this purpose alone cannot usually be used to identify you.
    Marketing
    The technical storage or access is required to create user profiles to send advertising, or to track the user on a website or across several websites for similar marketing purposes.
    • Manage options
    • Manage services
    • Manage {vendor_count} vendors
    • Read more about these purposes
    View preferences
    • {title}
    • {title}
    • {title}
    🇿🇦 Sign up to the TechCentral newsletter