TechCentralTechCentral
    Facebook Twitter YouTube LinkedIn
    Facebook Twitter LinkedIn YouTube
    TechCentral TechCentral
    NEWSLETTER
    • News

      Alviva shares leap higher on R3-billion take-private offer

      30 June 2022

      Datatec to sell Analysys Mason for as much as R4.1-billion

      30 June 2022

      Futuregrowth launches start-up fund, targets R600-million raise

      30 June 2022

      Eskom is killing the rand

      30 June 2022

      Eskom ramps up load shedding as crisis deepens

      30 June 2022
    • World

      Graphics card prices plummet as crypto demand dries up

      30 June 2022

      Bitcoin just had its worst quarter in a decade

      30 June 2022

      Samsung beats TSMC to 3nm chip production

      30 June 2022

      Napster plots crypto comeback

      29 June 2022

      Pictures: Chinese spacecraft acquires images of entire planet of Mars

      29 June 2022
    • In-depth

      The NFT party is over

      30 June 2022

      The great crypto crash: the fallout, and what happens next

      22 June 2022

      Goodbye, Internet Explorer – you really won’t be missed

      19 June 2022

      Oracle’s database dominance threatened by rise of cloud-first rivals

      13 June 2022

      Everything Apple announced at WWDC – in less than 500 words

      7 June 2022
    • Podcasts

      How your organisation can triage its information security risk

      22 June 2022

      Everything PC S01E06 – ‘Apple Silicon’

      15 June 2022

      The youth might just save us

      15 June 2022

      Everything PC S01E05 – ‘Nvidia: The Green Goblin’

      8 June 2022

      Everything PC S01E04 – ‘The story of Intel – part 2’

      1 June 2022
    • Opinion

      Has South Africa’s advertising industry lost its way?

      21 June 2022

      Rob Lith: What Icasa’s spectrum auction means for SA companies

      13 June 2022

      A proposed solution to crypto’s stablecoin problem

      19 May 2022

      From spectrum to roads, why fixing SA’s problems is an uphill battle

      19 April 2022

      How AI is being deployed in the fight against cybercriminals

      8 April 2022
    • Company Hubs
      • 1-grid
      • Altron Document Solutions
      • Amplitude
      • Atvance Intellect
      • Axiz
      • BOATech
      • CallMiner
      • Digital Generation
      • E4
      • ESET
      • Euphoria Telecom
      • IBM
      • Kyocera Document Solutions
      • Microsoft
      • Nutanix
      • One Trust
      • Pinnacle
      • Skybox Security
      • SkyWire
      • Tarsus on Demand
      • Videri Digital
      • Zendesk
    • Sections
      • Banking
      • Broadcasting and Media
      • Cloud computing
      • Consumer electronics
      • Cryptocurrencies
      • Education and skills
      • Energy
      • Fintech
      • Information security
      • Internet and connectivity
      • Internet of Things
      • Investment
      • IT services
      • Motoring and transport
      • Public sector
      • Science
      • Social media
      • Talent and leadership
      • Telecoms
    • Advertise
    TechCentralTechCentral
    Home»Opinion»Duncan McLeod»The day Icasa got lucky

    The day Icasa got lucky

    Duncan McLeod By Duncan McLeod6 April 2014
    Facebook Twitter LinkedIn WhatsApp Telegram Email

    Duncan-McLeod-180-profileBewilderment. That’s the word that best described the look on the faces of mobile communications industry executives crammed into a courtroom on the 11th floor of the high court in downtown Johannesburg on Monday afternoon as they listened to judge Haseena Mayat hand down her decision in a key industry battle.

    Mayat was reading highlights of her judgment in the legal showdown between MTN and Vodacom and industry regulator Icasa over call termination rates, the fees operators charge each other to carry calls between their networks. Icasa is reducing the rates, and introducing rules that favour smaller players financially, in the hopes of fostering competition and driving down retail prices.

    MTN and Vodacom asked for a final order blocking implementation of the rates. They won it, with the court finding that Icasa’s 2014 regulations governing call termination rates were “unlawful and invalid”. Then Mayat said something unexpected, drawing puzzled looks from many in the courtroom: even though the regulations were unlawful, she would suspend her decision for six months so that the rate cut would take effect as Icasa had planned. Doing so was in the “public interest”, Mayat said, explaining that she was empowered, legally, to act at her discretion in this regard.

    Despite this unexpected twist, the outcome was damning for Icasa: the two operators proved their legal arguments and showed that the regulatory agency had failed to do its job. Icasa got lucky.

    The regulator, which was quick to trumpet the outcome as a victory for consumers (it’s not clear at all that it is), had not taken into account the costs incurred by operators in terminating phone calls and the wholesale prices it had set were “irrational and arbitrary”.

    Instead of beating its chest, claiming some sort of victory, Icasa should reflect on what the court’s decision really means. The judgment again raises serious questions about its ability to meet its mandate of regulating in the public interest. Because of a faulty regulation-making process, it had to dig deep into its pockets — ultimately using taxpayers’ money to hire experienced and expensive senior counsel — to fight a court battle that may not have been necessary if it had simply done its job properly in the first place.

    Icasa can thank its lucky stars that the judge decided to use her discretion to implement the rates anyway for a limited period. It was able to use that decision to save face, even though the court’s findings were very much against it. It now has six months to craft new regulations, ensuring this time that they comply with the law.

    In this interim period, the court’s decision has, unfortunately, left the mobile communications industry in a state of flux. The judgment makes it harder for smaller operators to cut their retail rates and to force a fresh industry-wide price war. Would they want to cut prices if they’ll simply have to put them up again in six months’ time? After all, they don’t know what the next set of regulations will say.

    Tough questions need to be asked about how Icasa got it so wrong
    Questions need to be asked about how Icasa got it so wrong

    This uncertainty will make it difficult for smaller players to confirm their business plans beyond October, said Cell C acting CEO Jose Dos Santos shortly after the judgment was handed down. “It also negatively impacts on the smaller operators’ ability to bring down prices to ensure all South Africans have access to affordable communications,” he said.

    One hopes that Icasa will now review what went so badly wrong with its own processes that a high court judge felt justified in handing down a final (not an interim) order against it. It must ask itself the hard questions. Parliament’s portfolio committee on communications, which has oversight, should also probe the matter.

    The authority must then move swiftly to introduce new regulations that will stand up to legal scrutiny. It doesn’t have much time. Vodacom and MTN must, of course, also come to the party, opening their books to Icasa so that the agency can determine future termination rates based on the true costs of terminating a call. It would be bad news for everyone involved, including consumers, if this matter had to go back to court again.

    • Duncan McLeod is editor of TechCentral. Find him on Twitter
    • This column was first published in the Sunday Times
    Cell C Duncan McLeod Haseena Mayat Icasa Jose dos Santos MTN Vodacom
    Share. Facebook Twitter LinkedIn WhatsApp Telegram Email
    Previous ArticleMinister sidelining black manufacturers
    Next Article MTN warns of new Sim swap scam

    Related Posts

    Huawei, MTN to help build 5G-powered ‘smart mine’

    30 June 2022

    Clear the regulatory fog, ISPs urge Icasa

    30 June 2022

    E.tv: ‘We know we must vacate broadband spectrum bands’

    29 June 2022
    Add A Comment

    Comments are closed.

    Promoted

    Billetterie simplifies interactions between law firms and clients

    30 June 2022

    Think herding cats is tricky? Try herding a cloud

    29 June 2022

    How your business can help hybrid workers effectively

    28 June 2022
    Opinion

    Has South Africa’s advertising industry lost its way?

    21 June 2022

    Rob Lith: What Icasa’s spectrum auction means for SA companies

    13 June 2022

    A proposed solution to crypto’s stablecoin problem

    19 May 2022

    Subscribe to Updates

    Get the best South African technology news and analysis delivered to your e-mail inbox every morning.

    © 2009 - 2022 NewsCentral Media

    Type above and press Enter to search. Press Esc to cancel.