Close Menu
TechCentralTechCentral

    Subscribe to the newsletter

    Get the best South African technology news and analysis delivered to your e-mail inbox every morning.

    Facebook X (Twitter) YouTube LinkedIn
    WhatsApp Facebook X (Twitter) LinkedIn YouTube
    TechCentralTechCentral
    • News

      South African AI energy start-up in R32m funding round

      17 June 2025

      New platform helps homeowners avoid delays in property sales

      17 June 2025

      Vodacom CEO Joosub bags R71m in pay – but taxman will take a big cut

      17 June 2025

      Meta bets $72-billion on AI – and investors love it

      17 June 2025

      Major rift opens between Microsoft and OpenAI

      17 June 2025
    • World

      Trump Mobile dials into politics, profit and patriarchy

      17 June 2025

      Samsung plots health data hub to link users and doctors in real time

      17 June 2025

      Yahoo tries to make its mail service relevant again

      13 June 2025

      Qualcomm shows off new chip for AI smart glasses

      11 June 2025

      Trump tariffs to dim 2025 smartphone shipments

      4 June 2025
    • In-depth

      Grok promised bias-free chat. Then came the edits

      2 June 2025

      Digital fortress: We go inside JB5, Teraco’s giant new AI-ready data centre

      30 May 2025

      Sam Altman and Jony Ive’s big bet to out-Apple Apple

      22 May 2025

      South Africa unveils big state digital reform programme

      12 May 2025

      Is this the end of Google Search as we know it?

      12 May 2025
    • TCS

      TechCentral Nexus S0E1: Starlink, BEE and a new leader at Vodacom

      8 June 2025

      TCS+ | The future of mobile money, with MTN’s Kagiso Mothibi

      6 June 2025

      TCS+ | AI is more than hype: Workday execs unpack real human impact

      4 June 2025

      TCS | Sentiv, and the story behind the buyout of Altron Nexus

      3 June 2025

      TCS | Signal restored: Unpacking the Blue Label and Cell C turnaround

      28 May 2025
    • Opinion

      Beyond the box: why IT distribution depends on real partnerships

      2 June 2025

      South Africa’s next crisis? Being offline in an AI-driven world

      2 June 2025

      Digital giants boost South African news media – and get blamed for it

      29 May 2025

      Solar panic? The truth about SSEG, fines and municipal rules

      14 April 2025

      Data protection must be crypto industry’s top priority

      9 April 2025
    • Company Hubs
      • Africa Data Centres
      • AfriGIS
      • Altron Digital Business
      • Altron Document Solutions
      • Altron Group
      • Arctic Wolf
      • AvertITD
      • Braintree
      • CallMiner
      • CYBER1 Solutions
      • Digicloud Africa
      • Digimune
      • Domains.co.za
      • ESET
      • Euphoria Telecom
      • Incredible Business
      • iONLINE
      • Iris Network Systems
      • LSD Open
      • NEC XON
      • Network Platforms
      • Next DLP
      • Ovations
      • Paracon
      • Paratus
      • Q-KON
      • SevenC
      • SkyWire
      • Solid8 Technologies
      • Telit Cinterion
      • Tenable
      • Vertiv
      • Videri Digital
      • Wipro
      • Workday
    • Sections
      • AI and machine learning
      • Banking
      • Broadcasting and Media
      • Cloud services
      • Contact centres and CX
      • Cryptocurrencies
      • Education and skills
      • Electronics and hardware
      • Energy and sustainability
      • Enterprise software
      • Fintech
      • Information security
      • Internet and connectivity
      • Internet of Things
      • Investment
      • IT services
      • Lifestyle
      • Motoring
      • Public sector
      • Retail and e-commerce
      • Science
      • SMEs and start-ups
      • Social media
      • Talent and leadership
      • Telecoms
    • Events
    • Advertise
    TechCentralTechCentral
    Home » News » ‘Telkom is wrong’: Icasa hits back at spectrum lawsuit

    ‘Telkom is wrong’: Icasa hits back at spectrum lawsuit

    By Duncan McLeod1 February 2021
    Twitter LinkedIn Facebook WhatsApp Email Telegram Copy Link
    News Alerts
    WhatsApp
    Icasa chairman Keabetswe Modimoeng

    Communications regulator Icasa has hit back hard at Telkom’s application to interdict the upcoming spectrum auction, warning that if the company is successful, it will serve to entrench Vodacom and MTN’s “duopoly” – the very thing Telkom claims it wants to avoid.

    Telkom filed papers in the high court in Pretoria in late December seeking an interdict to stop Icasa from proceeding with the spectrum licensing process – needed to expand 4G and 5G network coverage in South Africa – until its concerns are addressed.

    The company’s group executive for regulatory affairs and government relations, Siyabonga Mahlangu, said in an interview with TechCentral at the time that it was approaching the court because it believes Icasa’s invitations to apply (ITAs) for spectrum and a planned wholesale open-access network (Woan) had fundamental flaws that could entrench the “dominance” of Vodacom and MTN.

    …Telkom seeks only to protect (its) own commercial interests to the disadvantage of the general population…

    Telkom wants temporary relief against Icasa, preventing the regulator from processing, assessing or adjudicating applications under the ITAs. It also wants the high court to review and set aside Icasa’s decision to issue the two ITAs.

    But now, in a hard-hitting responding affidavit lodged with the court, Icasa chairman Keabetswe Modimoeng has sought to tear Telkom’s argument apart, saying the company has no right in law to seek to interdict the crucial spectrum licensing process.

    “There is absolutely no constitutional basis for this court to grant the interim interdict (in) which Telkom seeks only to protect (its) own commercial interests to the disadvantage of the general population…,” Modimoeng said.

    Clock is ticking

    Icasa’s response to Telkom’s lawsuit comes about eight weeks before the regulator is expected to license spectrum in four key spectrum bands, including the “digital dividend” bands of 700MHZ and 800MHz still used by analogue television broadcasters. It is also facing a legal challenge from MTN South Africa, but on different grounds.

    If Telkom had a problem with the way Icasa proceeded with the spectrum licensing project, it had plenty of opportunity to do so as it has known for some time how the regulator intended to license the bands, including from a detailed Information Memorandum it published in November 2019.

    “The mere fact that Icasa arrived at a conclusion which is different from that which Telkom would have preferred … does not mean that Icasa’s decisions are unlawful or that they are irrational. In fact, it shows that the decisions … required Icasa to consider different policy objectives and balance competing interests…”

    Telkom’s Siyabonga Mahlangu

    Modimoeng has also taken umbrage at an assertion by Telkom that Icasa didn’t properly consider the state of competition in the sector when designing the auction.

    “Telkom is wrong,” he said. “Icasa appointed Acacia Economics, Cenerva and Real Wireless to advise it on all competition matters relevant to the current auction process. The relevant officials are international experts in the issues which are in dispute in this application and properly advised Icasa in its decision-making processes.”

    Also, the radio frequency spectrum regulations, published in 2015, require Icasa to assign high-demand spectrum (where demand is greater than supply) on a competitive basis. Icasa determined that an auction process was the most appropriate way to license the spectrum. An auction “facilitates transparency, efficiency and fairness in the process”, Modimoeng said.

    There is absolutely no factual basis to support Telkom’s contention that Icasa did not consider competition concerns

    There is also no need for Icasa to wait for the outcome of its own inquiry into competition in the mobile services market before designing the auction, as it is a “separate process”. Telkom has contended the outcome of this inquiry must be a core component of the auction ITA.

    “Icasa’s discussion document on its mobile broadband service inquiry and the Competition Commission’s data service market inquiry’s final report were considered before the finalisation and publication of the auction ITA. Consideration was given to, among other things, barriers to entry, retail and wholesale market shares, and market power and spectrum assignments pre-auction,” he said.

    ‘Must be rejected’

    “There is absolutely no factual basis to support Telkom’s contention that Icasa did not consider competition concerns. All of Telkom’s contentions founded on the allegation that Icasa did not take into account competition concerns must accordingly be rejected.”

    Furthermore, Modimoeng warned that if Telkom is successful in its court application, the auction process could be delayed by years, in effect entrenching any “duopoly” between Vodacom and MTN that Telkom contends exists.

    “Such a delay would only serve to prejudice Telkom and others and entrench the very same ‘duopoly’ of MTN and Vodacom which it says must be eradicated. The longer the status quo of the Vodacom and MTN ‘duopoly’ continues, the more difficult it is going to be to eradicate it and for Telkom to compete with them in the future – even if the process were to be delayed by one year,” Modimoeng said.

    Icasa also contends in its answering affidavit that there is no basis to Telkom’s argument that Icasa issued the ITAs knowing that the digital dividend bands are not yet available for use by mobile operators. “So, we will buy the spectrum, but we will not be able to get a return from it,” said Telkom’s Mahlangu in his December interview with TechCentral.

    But Modimoeng said this isn’t the case. “The correct position is that as soon as the auction process is completed and the relevant licences are awarded, the successful bidders will then become entitled to enjoy the full commercial benefits of the spectrum that would have been awarded to them,” he said. It’s an interesting assertion by Modimoeng given that, if the mobile operators were to use the digital dividend bands after the auction, they would likely cause interference with television broadcasts (without careful planning).

    Furthermore, when communications minister Stella Ndabeni-Abrahams directed Icasa to accept invitations to apply for spectrum and the Woan licence, she did not say that Icasa must first wait for the government to complete the digital migration process, Icasa said. “It is not surprising as to why the minister did not prescribe this as a condition for the auction process,” Modimoeng said.

    “The minister is clearly aware of the fact that the digital migration process is not an impediment to the issuing and processing of the ITAs. Neither did Telkom seek to set aside the 2019 policy for directing Icasa to issue both the auction ITA and the Woan ITA prior to completion of the digital migration process.”  — © 2021 NewsCentral Media

    Now read: MTN sues Icasa over 5G spectrum auction plan



    Competition Commission Icasa Keabetswe Modimoeng MTN MTN South Africa Stella Ndabeni-Abrahams Telkom top Vodacom Vodacom South Africa
    Subscribe to TechCentral Subscribe to TechCentral
    Share. Facebook Twitter LinkedIn WhatsApp Telegram Email Copy Link
    Previous ArticleHuge Group wins shareholder backing for Adapt IT bid
    Next Article SpaceX plans all-civilian space flight

    Related Posts

    Vodacom CEO Joosub bags R71m in pay – but taxman will take a big cut

    17 June 2025

    TechCentral Nexus S0E2: South Africa’s digital battlefield

    16 June 2025

    MVNO boom is reshaping South Africa’s mobile market

    12 June 2025
    Company News

    Altron: a brand journey, a birthday celebration and a bet on Joburg’s future

    17 June 2025

    7 benefits of social media integration in WordPress

    17 June 2025

    Paratus Zimbabwe and PowerTel strike milestone deal

    17 June 2025
    Opinion

    Beyond the box: why IT distribution depends on real partnerships

    2 June 2025

    South Africa’s next crisis? Being offline in an AI-driven world

    2 June 2025

    Digital giants boost South African news media – and get blamed for it

    29 May 2025

    Subscribe to Updates

    Get the best South African technology news and analysis delivered to your e-mail inbox every morning.

    © 2009 - 2025 NewsCentral Media

    Type above and press Enter to search. Press Esc to cancel.