TechCentralTechCentral
    Facebook Twitter YouTube LinkedIn
    Facebook Twitter LinkedIn YouTube
    TechCentralTechCentral
    NEWSLETTER
    • News

      Fixing SA’s power crisis is not complex: it simply takes the will to do better

      12 August 2022

      Consortium makes unsolicited bid for state’s 40% stake in Telkom

      12 August 2022

      Actually, solar users should pay more to access the grid – here’s why

      12 August 2022

      Telkom says MTN talks remain on track

      12 August 2022

      Analysis | Rain muddies the waters with approach to Telkom

      11 August 2022
    • World

      Tencent woes mount, even after $560-billion selloff

      12 August 2022

      Huawei just booked its first sales rise since US blacklisting

      12 August 2022

      Apple remains upbeat about iPhone sales even as Android world suffers

      12 August 2022

      Ether at two-month high as upgrade to blockchain passes major test

      12 August 2022

      Gaming industry’s fortunes fade as pandemic ends

      11 August 2022
    • In-depth

      African unicorn Flutterwave battles fires on multiple fronts

      11 August 2022

      The length of Earth’s days has been increasing – and no one knows why

      7 August 2022

      As Facebook fades, the Mad Men of advertising stage a comeback

      2 August 2022

      Crypto breaks the rules. That’s the point

      27 July 2022

      E-mail scams are getting chillingly personal

      17 July 2022
    • Podcasts

      Qush on infosec: why prevention is always better than cure

      11 August 2022

      e4’s Adri Führi on encouraging more women into tech careers

      10 August 2022

      How South Africa can woo more women into tech

      4 August 2022

      Book and check-in via WhatsApp? FlySafair is on it

      28 July 2022

      Interview: Why Dell’s next-gen PowerEdge servers change the game

      28 July 2022
    • Opinion

      No reason South Africa should have a shortage of electricity: Ramaphosa

      11 July 2022

      Ntshavheni’s bias against the private sector

      8 July 2022

      South Africa can no longer rely on Eskom alone

      4 July 2022

      Has South Africa’s advertising industry lost its way?

      21 June 2022

      Rob Lith: What Icasa’s spectrum auction means for SA companies

      13 June 2022
    • Company Hubs
      • 1-grid
      • Altron Document Solutions
      • Amplitude
      • Atvance Intellect
      • Axiz
      • BOATech
      • CallMiner
      • Digital Generation
      • E4
      • ESET
      • Euphoria Telecom
      • IBM
      • Kyocera Document Solutions
      • Microsoft
      • Nutanix
      • One Trust
      • Pinnacle
      • Skybox Security
      • SkyWire
      • Tarsus on Demand
      • Videri Digital
      • Zendesk
    • Sections
      • Banking
      • Broadcasting and Media
      • Cloud computing
      • Consumer electronics
      • Cryptocurrencies
      • Education and skills
      • Energy
      • Fintech
      • Information security
      • Internet and connectivity
      • Internet of Things
      • Investment
      • IT services
      • Motoring and transport
      • Public sector
      • Science
      • Social media
      • Talent and leadership
      • Telecoms
    • Advertise
    TechCentralTechCentral
    Home»Opinion»Andrew Rens»Don’t repeat copyright mistakes

    Don’t repeat copyright mistakes

    Andrew Rens By Editor11 March 2010
    Facebook Twitter LinkedIn WhatsApp Telegram Email

    Andrew Rens

    [By Andrew Rens] In a recent interview with TechCentral, Owen Dean of specialist intellectual property lawfirm Spoor & Fisher urges that SA should ratify a treaty that requires anti-circumvention provisions meant to stop copyright infringement.

    According to Dean, the country must “follow in the footsteps of the majors, and we’re not doing that. If the footsteps turn out to be less effective than originally envisaged, then so be it”.

    Is he really advocating that SA makes the same mistakes as other countries?

    The 1996 Performances and Phonograms Treaty creates new rights for the manufacturers of recordings of music and film and requires these awkwardly named “anti-circumvention provisions”.

    These provisions are legal rules that prohibit working around the technical restrictions copyright holders use in their digital products. They give additional legal powers to rights holders, and impose additional restrictions on everyone else.

    Twelve years ago, the US enacted provisions like these in the Digital Millennium Copyright Act (DMCA). Among other things, the provisions made it illegal for researchers to point out security vulnerabilities caused by the now infamous Sony root-kit, exposing purchasers of the Japanese company’s products to the risk of security breaches.

    The same law is used to try to prevent US consumers from having their cellphones freed from being locked to one cellular network. After 12 years of experience with these anti-circumvention provisions, leading US copyright experts are now calling for the abolition of the DMCA.

    Anti-circumvention provisions are not just ineffective. They also stifle free speech and innovation.

    As a direct result of problems with the treaty, there are many countries have declined to ratify it. Emerging economies Brazil and India have not signed the treaty, and Canada, like SA, has signed but not ratified it. And the UK Intellectual Property Commission recommended “other countries should not follow the lead of the US and the EU by implementing legislation on the lines of the DMCA”.

    It’s true that SA copyright law needs a complete overhaul. But the impetus should not come from discredited treaties. Instead, the law needs to change to allow, among other things, greater innovation, online education, and “format-shifting” for the visually impaired.

    SA’s Copyright Act was gazetted in 1978 by an apartheid government intent on demonstrating to the world that the country was akin to Europe. We never had a copyright drafting process that took into account that SA is a developing country. Users’ rights, which are termed exceptions in the legislation, have proved inadequate in promoting education and innovation.

    Also, rapid technological change has made the problems with the act worse.
    SA should rewrite the act, drawing on lessons learnt in other countries. For example, we could draw on UK copyright law, which permits decompiling software to ensure interoperability of systems, debugging to ensure products work across a range of systems, and reverse engineering to determine algorithms and other underlying principles that are not subject to copyright.

    Anti-circumvention legislation makes it illegal for consumers who have paid for a product, like a DVD, to make a copy of it, even for a permitted use like personal study.

    Technical blocks, often euphemistically termed DRM, or digital rights management, also impose restrictions such as regional coding which have nothing to do with copying. Region coding, which prevents consumers from, for example, playing a US-made DVD in an SA-bought DVD player, has no basis in copyright law – it’s an additional limitation some vendors have chosen to impose on their customers.

    Anti-circumvention provisions prohibit a purchaser from finding a way around DRM schemes such as region coding. The bizarre thing is, these schemes have generally failed to prevent large-scale commercial copying of CDs and DVDs — infringers simply copy the DRM together with the other data on the disc.

    What benefit, if any, could these schemes provide? McKinsey researchers have shown the vast majority of musicians do not make any money from CD sales. Musicians are often forced to tour to make money to pay record companies for marketing costs of CDs. According to the McKinsey researchers, musicians mostly make money from live appearances, while the record companies pocket the profits from music recordings.

    Madonna has fired her record companies, while Radiohead is profiting from a direct-to-fan business model.

    Musicians and other creative people are finding new business models, often through new intermediaries such as Apple iTunes and Amazon.com. One consequence of anti-circumvention provisions is to give record labels and movie studios control over which appliances can play their products, which translates into power over consumer electronics companies.

    These provisions are at play in the battle between different groups of information intermediaries. It would be a mistake for SA to adopt measures that have failed to prop up obsolete business models just for the sake of being seen to be doing something.

    • Andrew Rens recently completed a three-year fellowship working on intellectual property issues at the Shuttleworth Foundation and teaches intellectual property law at the University of Cape Town. The article expresses his personal views
    • The photo of Rens is courtesy of the Shuttleworth Foundation — 2008 CC_BY_SA_2.5_Za (Creative Commons Attribution Share-Alike South Africa 2.5)
    • Subscribe to our free daily newsletter
    • Follow us on Twitter or on Facebook
    Andrew Rens Owen Dean Spoor & Fisher
    Share. Facebook Twitter LinkedIn WhatsApp Telegram Email
    Previous ArticleBilling snafu, Rica hit MTN hard
    Next Article Gov’t moves ahead on broadband, spectrum policies

    Related Posts

    No reason South Africa should have a shortage of electricity: Ramaphosa

    11 July 2022

    Ntshavheni’s bias against the private sector

    8 July 2022

    South Africa can no longer rely on Eskom alone

    4 July 2022
    Add A Comment

    Comments are closed.

    Promoted

    Get your brand in front of TechCentral’s amazing audience

    12 August 2022

    Pricing Beyond CMYK: printers answer the FAQs

    11 August 2022

    How secure is your cloud?

    10 August 2022
    Opinion

    No reason South Africa should have a shortage of electricity: Ramaphosa

    11 July 2022

    Ntshavheni’s bias against the private sector

    8 July 2022

    South Africa can no longer rely on Eskom alone

    4 July 2022

    Subscribe to Updates

    Get the best South African technology news and analysis delivered to your e-mail inbox every morning.

    © 2009 - 2022 NewsCentral Media

    Type above and press Enter to search. Press Esc to cancel.